揽瓜阁逻辑做题小分队 第24天

HelloWorld~

CB

大月亮cyn

Day24
1. [Weaken] A 所以公路沿线这些动物多不等于森林深处多
P observations along the newly constructed highway ----> many large herbivores such as deer and moose are grazing there
P many near the road = more abundant in more distant reaches of the forest
C construction of the new highway NO THREATENED
2. [Evaluation] B
P C恐龙的胃附近有C的骨头
C C是cannibalism吃同类？
B --> 可能是jumbled together 一起的 不代表在胃化石附近的就是吃下去的

lfengi

Weaken: A
P: many large herbivores such as deer and moose are grazing around the newly construction road.
P: The reported numbers are about equal to our overall population estimates of the past three years
C1: if there are that many near the road, the animals must be even more abundant in more distant reaches of the forest.
Main Conclusion: concerns that local populations of these animals are threatened by the construction of the new highway are clearly misplaced
A:不一定森林深处更多因为有食肉动物的存在， 食肉动物不愿意靠近公路 – 削弱结论

Evaluation: B (此题不会)
P: Paleontologists in 1947 found a large group of fossilized skeletons of the carnivorous dinosaur Coelophysis. In the space where one Coelophysis's stomach had been, there were bones from another individual of the same species
C: Coelophysis was cannibalistic.
A – 其他动物的骨头与本题无关
B – 不同个体的C恐龙的骨头多大程度的混杂在一起
C – 同A
D – 同A
E – 这个选项无论回答是Yes 还是No 都不能否定或者肯定C恐龙是否吃同类