[费费逻辑求解]矛盾的第九题

两天软脚虾

首先这是原题的题目和对应解释：



9. Astronauts who experience weightlessness frequently get motion sickness. The astronauts see their own motion relative to passing objects, but while the astronauts are weightless their inner ears indicate that their bodies are not moving. The astronauts’ experience is best explained by the hypothesis that conflicting information received by the brain about the body’s motion causes motion sickness.

Which one of the following, if true, provides the strongest additional support for the hypothesis above?

A.        During rough voyages ship passengers in cabins providing a view of the water are less likely to get motion sickness than are passengers in cabins providing no view.
B.        Many people who are experienced airplane passengers occasionally get motion sickness.
C.        Some automobile passengers whose inner ears indicate that they are moving and who have a clear view of the objects they are passing get motion sickness.
D.        People who have aisle seats in trains or airplanes are as likely to get motion sickness as are people who have window seats.
E.        Some astronauts do not get motion sickness even after being in orbit for several days.

答案：A
思路：搭桥法，建立A与B的联系。仔细读题可知：这种运动性疾病是由于大脑接受了不同的矛盾的信息。有两个信息源：一个来自内耳（静止），一个来自眼睛（运动）。
选项中只有A,C,D涉及这样两个信息源。
A指出接受两种不同的信息较容易获得运动性疾病比起获得两种一致的信息。C：虽有两种信息，但两者是一致的（都是运动的）。
C, D：指出接受两种一致的信息较容易获得运动性疾病比起获得两种不同的信息。与题目的例子相反。所以只有A是正确选项。



我的疑问，虽然A确实反映了conflicting information, 但是从A的意思来看，能看到水的passenger(moving的水告诉自己在动，身体告诉自己没在动)，按照hypothesis,应该要得motion sickness.结果是less likely.

所以我认为A不是support,而是weaken。
求解

shanelavigne

哈哈哈哈 你是不是做题做懵了啊 A选项就是会得motion sickness的啊 当然是支持stem的观点的

两天软脚虾

shanelavigne 发表于 2017-10-23 16:11
哈哈哈哈 你是不是做题做懵了啊 A选项就是会得motion sickness的啊 当然是支持stem的观点的 ...

他不是说看到水的那个人less likely得吗？