大全上的一道题？

lisiberry

Ross: The profitability of Company X, restored to private ownership five years ago, is clear evidence that businesses will always fare better under private than under public ownership.
Julia: Wrong. A close look at the records shows that X has been profitable since the appointment of a first-class manager, which happened while X was still in the pubic sector.

Which of the following best describes the weak point in Ross’s claim on which Julia’s response focuses?

(A) The evidence Ross cites comes from only a single observed case, that of Company X.
(B) The profitability of Company X might be only temporary.
(C) Ross’s statement leaves open the possibility that the cause he cites came after the effect he attributes to it.
(D) No mention is made of companies that are partly government owned and partly privately owned.
(E) No exact figures are given for the current profits of Company X.

OA：C

百般不解。C选项中Ross提到了he。说明Ross是男的？还是说he指的是经理？

Bradz

he指的是ross.

alzn2765

这种题型GMAT也不考。
你根据prep比对，prep里没有的一定就是只有LSAT才考的

RRZZR

he就是Ross。。（完了发现代沟了。。。。其实有个电视剧叫Friends....不是爱情公寓啊...

这题是就是要抽象出来Julia批评Ross的点。
Company X 5年前由public转为private ，（现在profitability比以前好），所以Ross说这肯定就是由于private ownership比public ownership好。然后Julia不同意，理由是X自还是public的时候就已经是profitable了，profitable的原因是manager好。

其实Julia的反驳真的是漏洞百出，随便挑几个可以写个七宗罪的awa了...

lisiberry

alzn2765 发表于 2017-3-2 10:00
这种题型GMAT也不考。
你根据prep比对，prep里没有的一定就是只有LSAT才考的

Alzn老师好，

谢谢，没事，我OG做了很多了，想做点新题。
即使是几道不考的也想看看。毕竟您把这些题都做了，才打下了如此牢固的基础。

lisiberry

RRZZR 发表于 2017-3-2 12:17
he就是Ross。。（完了发现代沟了。。。。其实有个电视剧叫Friends....不是爱情公寓啊...

这题是就是要 ...

明白了，谢谢。

Rose是女的，Ross是男的。
一个名字没理解到位，导致犹豫了半天。

没有代沟，我同学也都看六人行，只是我当时没看而已

lisiberry

Bradz 发表于 2017-3-2 08:29
he指的是ross.

十分感谢，Ross跟Rose原来是正好相反的性别呀。明白了。

穆汐寒

我只是比较好奇，如果反驳L的话用该从哪里入手？

穆汐寒

穆汐寒 发表于 2017-3-2 20:48
我只是比较好奇，如果反驳L的话用该从哪里入手？

打错了，J的话

lisiberry

穆汐寒 发表于 2017-3-2 20:48
打错了，J的话

比如，虽然X公司在是公共部门时盈利，但没有变成私有部门后盈利的多。