国内的一些有名的商学院MBA项目如中欧国际的MBA等相当于美国的排名多少的商学院呢？

心如止水

以下是引用jeremy2000在2005-4-6 9:31:00的发言：
楼主发此贴的目的不是在于比较，而是在于择校，希望能听听大家的看法而帮助他选择合适的学校。大家就畅所欲言吧！

说得好!

oasis_beijing

以下是引用adios在2005-4-5 9:49:00的发言：

if a "top" school can't land you a job, then "top school" = nothing.

How do you know a top50 US b-school cannot 'land' you a job? probably no any school can guarantee all the students find a 'good' job 3 months after graduation. but it depends on everyone's choise. You cannot judge the quality of school only by this.

how old the school is get nothing to do with its "prestigious" or not.

for example INSEAD was founded in 1957. who dares to say those "hundred-year-old" US-schools are better than INSEAD?!

I cannot agree. People can judge a chool's quality by its history. It's one element we should count in. Why Peking Univ. ranks top 1 or top 2 in China but cannot enter top 100 in the world? Probably because all Chinese univ. has short history than US/European shools.

if you want to stay in the US, then US based schools definitely give you much better chances.

if you want to come back to China, do you think someone will give you better chance just because of you graduated from a "top20-top50" US-school? i highly doubt it.

Not exactly. If depends on which industry and which company you want to join. In most cases, the network of alumni can provide great help. So do you think the network of top 50 US b-schools are not as good as those of China? Definetely no.

eternalwind

说句老实话, 如果以后决定在国内发展的话, 除了TOP 15的商学院外, 其他的真还不如中欧

如果想留在美国或者其他什么地方, 那就另当别论

hanlin

You can check the rank of BusinessWeek, Financial Times and WallStreet.

Anyway, CEIBS is strong in local network and weak in multinational environment, including English.

zdcgy

以下是引用eternalwind在2005-4-7 13:26:00的发言：

说句老实话, 如果以后决定在国内发展的话, 除了TOP 15的商学院外, 其他的真还不如中欧

如果想留在美国或者其他什么地方, 那就另当别论

I agree. I guess the quality of CEIBS' students are similar to those of top15-50 US schools, which means most CEIBS students, if they wish, can be admitted by these schools too.(or even top10)

adios

以下是引用oasis_beijing在2005-4-7 13:22:00的发言：

How do you know a top50 US b-school cannot 'land' you a job? probably no any school can guarantee all the students find a 'good' job 3 months after graduation. but it depends on everyone's choise. You cannot judge the quality of school only by this.

i don't know that "a top50 US b-school cannot land you a job".

because i said "if".

so your argument is shooting at nowhere.

I cannot agree. People can judge a chool's quality by its history. It's one element we should count in. Why Peking Univ. ranks top 1 or top 2 in China but cannot enter top 100 in the world? Probably because all Chinese univ. has short history than US/European shools.

so tell me about INSEAD.

it has only 50 years' of history. why it's considered much better than those US based top-50 schools w/ more than 100 years?

why bejing univ. is not among the top-100 in the world?

it is not because of its "short" history. it is because of the lack of money.

again. tell me why w/ only 50 years of history, INSEAD is one of the best?

can you explain? your "history" story apparently does not work.

Not exactly. If depends on which industry and which company you want to join. In most cases, the network of alumni can provide great help. So do you think the network of top 50 US b-schools are not as good as those of China? Definetely no.

"definitely no"? ha. the answer is a "definitely yes".

jeremy2000

北大清华之所以不能排进前100名，不是因为它的历史短，也不是因为它没有钱，而是因为教学语言采用的是中文，教学模式也是中国的模式，和北美及欧洲的教学模式不一样，所以无法采用国际的标准来评估他们，因此也排不进世界前列。呵呵，我做国际教育的，这方面的事情我还是略知一二的。

gmatgwd

以下是引用zdcgy在2005-4-8 3:24:00的发言：

I agree. I guess the quality of CEIBS' students are similar to those of top15-50 US schools, which means most CEIBS students, if they wish, can be admitted by these schools too.(or even top10)

Who told you that? 640 or less can open the door of CEIBS, how about the TOP 30 in US? It is true CEIBS has a strong network in China, and it may help you find a not bad job. But the quality of China's MBA program cannot compare with TOP 30 in the US. Think about the LBS, a very good England BS, the students there are all struggling to win the chance to be an exchange students in a top 50 business school in US.

4star-admiral

Who told you that? 640 or less can open the door of CEIBS, how about the TOP 30 in US? It is true CEIBS has a strong network in China, and it may help you find a not bad job. But the quality of China's MBA program cannot compare with TOP 30 in the US. Think about the LBS, a very good England BS, the students there are all struggling to win the chance to be an exchange students in a top 50 business school in US.

AGREE!

zdcgy

以下是引用gmatgwd在2005-4-10 17:13:00的发言：

Who told you that? 640 or less can open the door of CEIBS, how about the TOP 30 in US? It is true CEIBS has a strong network in China, and it may help you find a not bad job. But the quality of China's MBA program cannot compare with TOP 30 in the US. Think about the LBS, a very good England BS, the students there are all struggling to win the chance to be an exchange students in a top 50 business school in US.

No one told me about that, as it is my guess only.

Studying MBA in US now, I am, too, not comfortable with CEIBS' higher ranking than many of US programs. I agree that Top50 US programs are stronger than CEIBS in terms of reputation, history, faculty and research, etc. But in terms of students' quality, I may not think so. As one of the New Oriental School's teachers said, going abroad for study is no longer a priviledge, but only a choice. (of course, for those non top programs only)

Anyhow, MBA is a professional certificate that invites hugh amount of tuition, and thus has a relatively higher acceptance rate. There are many top50 programs that have an acceptance rate of 50% or more.