急问GWD9-5

jiangyue_yue

why nobody help me?

craftfat

Why GWD-9-Q6 picks D?

Although choice C (a single group to maintain control over the production process) seems correct, it does not fully contain all the information in the passage.

Consider the sentence "The commodities produced in these zones were extracted, processed, and transported entirely by members of a single group."

Obviously, the extraction and transportion are not mentioned in choice C. Since C does not fully express the whole idea in the passage, it is not an perfect answer.

Choice D is derived from one sentence which relates the problem of resource distribution and the inhibitants' solution in paragraph 1. 

"Given this unequal (15) resource distribution, highland Incas needed access to the products of lower, warmer climatic zones in order to enlarge the variety and quantity of their foodstuffs."

As you can see from the sentence, "access" and "lower, warmer zones" are the key ideas.

The ideas are summarized in choice D.

My analysis suggests that you got to pay attention to eliminate the inaccurate choice in GWD.

Theose seeming perfect choices are traps. 

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-12-10 19:19:25编辑过]

gonghao

第五题

题名问，according to the text，那么说明答案一定是在文中explicitly stated （OG11的解释经常提到）

they relied primarily

on the maintenance of autonomous

production forces in as many ecological

zones as possible.
            

那么根据下面红色的这一段，我觉得答案就应该是A

snowofjune

up

qianrene

以下是引用gonghao在2007-7-7 16:57:00的发言：

第五题

题名问，according to the text，那么说明答案一定是在文中explicitly stated （OG11的解释经常提到）

they relied primarily

on the maintenance of autonomous

production forces in as many ecological

zones as possible.
   

那么根据下面红色的这一段，我觉得答案就应该是A

While most

of the Incas were self-sufficient

agriculturists

---

结合前面一句看就不会选A了：

自给自足是本来就有了，不是为了解决unequal而采取的，在文章中这段也是在问题的前面，楼上那句的关键应该放在as many as zones而不应该放在一个词autonomous（这里只是顺便提了下前面提过的内容）

superwangche

以下是引用craftfat在2006-12-10 16:02:00的发言：

Why GWD-9-Q6 picks D?

Although choice C (a single group to maintain control over the production process) seems correct, it does not fully contain all the information in the passage.

Consider the sentence "The commodities produced in these zones were extracted, processed, and transported entirely by members of a single group."

Obviously, the extraction and transportion are not mentioned in choice C. Since C does not fully express the whole idea in the passage, it is not an perfect answer.

Choice D is derived from one sentence which relates the problem of resource distribution and the inhibitants' solution in paragraph 1. 

"Given this unequal (15) resource distribution, highland Incas needed access to the products of lower, warmer climatic zones in order to enlarge the variety and quantity of their foodstuffs."

As you can see from the sentence, "access" and "lower, warmer zones" are the key ideas.

The ideas are summarized in choice D.

My analysis suggests that you got to pay attention to eliminate the inaccurate choice in GWD.

Theose seeming perfect choices are traps. 

我也选的D. 牛牛们能不能给解释一下D为什么不好么？

snowlemon

同问，做了两次都选d