转发商学院研究能力排名2005-2009 对PHD选校很有帮助

cherryruj

http://som.utdallas.edu/top100Ranking/searchRanking.php?t=w
The UTD Top 100 World Rankings of Business Schools Based on Research Contribution 2005-2009

Rank	University	Articles	Score	Country
1	University of Pennsylvania (The Wharton School)	314	160.48	USA
2	Duke University (The Fuqua School of Business)	247	129.18	USA
3	New York University (Leonard N. Stern School of Business)	258	123.35	USA
4	University of Chicago (Booth School of Business)	206	116.58	USA
5	Harvard University (Harvard Business School)	192	112.03	USA
6	University of Michigan at Ann Arbor (Ross School of Business)	218	111.74	USA
7	University of Maryland at College Park (Robert H. Smith School of Business)	206	105.58	USA
8	Columbia University (Graduate School of Business)	204	101.34	USA
9	Stanford University (Graduate School of Business)	186	97.58	USA
10	University of Texas at Austin (McCombs School of Business)	180	88.75	USA
11	University of Southern California (Marshall School of Business)	158	83.91	USA
12	INSEAD	157	82.13	FRANCE
13	Massachusetts Institute of Technology (Sloan School of Management)	163	81.44	USA
14	University of Minnesota at Twin Cities (Carlson School of Management)	154	79.45	USA
15	Northwestern University (Kellogg School of Management)	154	79.09	USA
16	Pennsylvania State University at University Park (Smeal College of Business)	149	78.22	USA
17	University of Texas at Dallas (School of Management)	129	69.54	USA
18	Hong Kong University of Science and Technology	124	66.42	China
19	London Business School	136	64.86	United Kingdom
20	University of California at Los Angeles (Anderson School of Management)	125	63.36	USA
21	University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (College of Business)	115	60.90	USA
22	University of California at Berkeley (Walter A. Haas School of Business)	115	60.17	USA
23	Arizona State University (W.P. Carey School of Business)	123	59.27	USA
24	Indiana University at Bloomington (Kelley School of Business)	117	57.10	USA
25	University of Washington at Seattle (Michael G. Foster School of Business)	113	55.28	USA
26	University of Florida (Warrington College of Business)	96	54.46	USA
27	Michigan State University (The Eli Broad College of Business)	110	54.29	USA
28	Carnegie Mellon University (Tepper School of Business)	107	52.73	USA
29	University of Toronto (Joseph L. Rotman School of Management)	98	51.69	Canada
30	Washington University at St. Louis (Olin School of Business)	100	51.37	USA
31	University of British Columbia (Sauder School of Business)	107	50.63	Canada
32	Cornell University (Samuel Curtis Johnson Graduate School of Management)	106	50.38	USA
33	Ohio State University (Fisher College of Business)	117	49.93	USA
34	University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (Kenan-Flagler Business School)	108	48.96	USA
35	Emory University (Goizueta Business School)	100	47.86	USA
36	Texas A&M University at College Station (Mays Business School)	105	46.63	USA
37	Georgia Institute of Technology (College of Management)	91	42.93	USA
38	Yale University (School of Management)	78	40.93	USA
39	University of Wisconsin at Madison (Wisconsin School of Business)	82	39.87	USA
40	University of Pittsburgh (The Joseph M. Katz Graduate School of Business)	78	37.13	USA
41	University of Iowa (Henry B. Tippie College of Business)	64	36.65	USA
42	University of California at Irvine (Paul Merage School of Business)	71	36.19	USA
43	Boston College (Carroll School of Management)	70	34.41	USA
44	Tilburg University (Faculty of Economics and Business Administration)	80	33.25	The Netherlands
45	Purdue University (Krannert Graduate School of Management)	66	33.11	USA
46	Dartmouth College (Tuck School of Business)	65	33.09	USA
47	University of South Carolina at Columbia (Moore School of Business)	60	31.54	USA
47	City University of New York, Baruch College (Zicklin School of Business)	58	31.54	USA
49	University of Miami (School of Business Administration)	59	31.41	USA
49	Erasmus University (Rotterdam School of Management)	63	31.41	The Netherlands
51	University of Utah (David Eccles School of Business)	66	30.91	USA
52	National University of Singapore (Business School)	73	30.57	Singapore
53	Rice University (Jesse H. Jones Graduate School of Management)	59	30.47	USA
54	University of Notre Dame (Mendoza College of Business)	58	30.24	USA
55	University of Western Ontario (Richard Ivey School of Business)	57	29.72	Canada
56	Rutgers University at New Brunswick and Newark (Rutgers Business School)	66	29.52	USA
57	Georgia State University (J. Mack Robinson School of Business)	61	28.82	USA
58	University of Connecticut (School of Business)	62	28.63	USA
59	University of Arizona (Eller College of Management)	60	27.56	USA
60	Southern Methodist University (Edwin L. Cox School of Business)	54	25.60	USA
61	McGill University (Desautels Faculty of Management)	50	24.78	Canada
62	Boston University (School of Management)	48	24.56	USA
63	University of Rochester (William E. Simon Graduate School of Business)	43	24.36	USA
64	University of Houston (C.T. Bauer College of Business)	47	24.31	USA
65	Singapore Management University (Lee Kong Chian School of Business)	56	23.84	Singapore
66	University of Alberta (School of Business)	43	22.76	Canada
67	Brigham Young University (Marriott School of Management)	37	22.36	USA
68	York University (Schulich School of Business)	45	22.16	Canada
69	University of California at Davis (Graduate School of Management)	43	21.53	USA
70	Hong Kong Polytechnic University (Graduate School of Business)	32	21.24	China
71	Vanderbilt University (Owen Graduate School of Management)	40	19.73	USA
72	University of Georgia (Terry College of Business)	43	19.57	USA
73	Tulane University (A. B. Freeman School of Business)	35	18.82	USA
74	University of Colorado at Boulder (Leeds School of Business)	42	18.64	USA
75	Chinese University of Hong Kong (Faculty of Business Administration)	44	17.96	China
76	HEC Montreal	37	17.94	Canada
77	Nanyang Technological University (Nanyang Business School)	36	17.59	Singapore
78	INSEAD, Singapore ( )	34	17.36	Singapore
79	University of New South Wales (Australian Graduate School of Management)	37	16.92	Australia
80	University of Oklahoma (Michael F. Price College of Business)	39	16.83	USA
81	Georgetown University (The McDonough School of Business)	37	16.39	USA
82	HEC France	41	16.11	France
83	University of Arkansas at Fayetteville (Sam M. Walton College of Business)	36	16.06	USA
84	Case Western Reserve University (Weatherhead School of Management)	33	15.86	USA
85	Simon Fraser University (Faculty of Business Administration)	34	15.76	Canada
86	University of California at Riverside (A. Gary Anderson Graduate School of Management)	36	15.69	USA
87	Temple University (The Fox School of Business and Management)	39	15.19	USA
88	University of Calgary (Haskayne School of Business)	23	15.08	Canada
89	University of Missouri at Columbia (Robert J. Trulaske, Sr. College of Business)	34	15.03	USA
90	City University of Hong Kong (Faculty of Business)	39	14.83	China
91	University of Melbourne (Melbourne Business School)	26	14.64	Australia
92	University of Virginia, Darden (Darden Graduate School of Business Administration)	38	14.60	USA
93	University of Oregon (Charles H. Lundquist College of Business)	29	14.12	USA
94	Copenhagen Business School	26	13.54	Denmark
95	University of Hong Kong ( )	31	13.43	China
96	George Washington University (School of Business)	27	13.27	USA
97	University of Texas at Arlington (College of Business)	27	12.94	USA
98	University of Mannheim ( )	22	12.70	Germany
99	Maastricht University ( )	28	12.65	The Netherlands
100	State University of New York at Buffalo (School of Management)	28	12.54	USA

2005-2009 ranking result last updated: February 25, 2010

gwendolinecn

Thanks for the information.

galluplinc

申OB的最好别参考这个排名，OB方面有几本重要的journal都不在排名参照范围之内

zzmypster

很久以前不是有人发过了么……

kndx5

too much bias

fzxc613

could u plz be more specifically where is the bias from?
what's the unbiased ranking in ur mind?

too much bias

-- by 会员 kndx5 (2010/11/28 1:36:04)

kndx5

第一，没有按照faculty人数scale。这种排名，闭着眼睛都能猜到wharton和nyu这种狂屯老师的学校会排的很靠前。不过mit表示压力不大，我们人少。

第二，没有考虑有的学校缺少部分专业。yale只有三个专业，所以最后排到了38，但是明眼人都知道，前面起码有25个学校在yale有的专业里面是不如yale的。

第三，选择的journal不均衡。utdallas的om和is很强，所以这个排名里边选了8个这方面的journal，而fin，act，mkt三个大系一共才10个journal。如果你只选择om和is的8个journal，05-09utdallas能排第3，如果你选择fin，act，mkt的10个journal，utdallas只能排第43，而最后全加在一起排到17。

anyway，任何排名都有bias，这东西就是个参考。

could u plz be more specifically where is the bias from?
what's the unbiased ranking in ur mind?

too much bias

-- by 会员 kndx5 (2010/11/28 1:36:04)

-- by 会员 fzxc613 (2010/11/29 4:05:54)

judydongxueni

解释的很给力哈哈

equn

6楼解释给力。

fzxc613

I don't agree.
   First, I'm not sure why does the ranking needed to be scaled by the # of faculty member? this is the ranking of overall faculty productivity not average  productivity of faculty . more faculty-> student have more choice. I don't see any bias here.
   Second, this is the overall ranking of the management school,not a ranking by major. It tries to measure the overall productivity of the  management school. Because of this, I would say it is very fair to list Yale as the 38th since they don't have some majors. This is Yale's fault, not ranking's fault or biased.
   Third, point is well taken. however, they only choose a little bit more OM and IS journal,  which is 4 (8/2)journals per major. For marketing, finance, acct, it is 3.33 (10/3)   journals per major.  Although there are some bias, I don't see too much.
   BTW, although they are kind of close, OM and IS are still two majors not one. Don't mislead     readers implicitly.
   BTW, in finance, we only consider JF, RFS and JFE are top journal for tenures review. thus, I  think choosing 3 journals in finance is pretty fairy . I don't know other majors.

第一，没有按照faculty人数scale。这种排名，闭着眼睛都能猜到wharton和nyu这种狂屯老师的学校会排的很靠前。不过mit表示压力不大，我们人少。

第二，没有考虑有的学校缺少部分专业。yale只有三个专业，所以最后排到了38，但是明眼人都知道，前面起码有25个学校在yale有的专业里面是不如yale的。

第三，选择的journal不均衡。utdallas的om和is很强，所以这个排名里边选了8个这方面的journal，而fin，act，mkt三个大系一共才10个journal。如果你只选择om和is的8个journal，05-09utdallas能排第3，如果你选择fin，act，mkt的10个journal，utdallas只能排第43，而最后全加在一起排到17。

anyway，任何排名都有bias，这东西就是个参考。

could u plz be more specifically where is the bias from?
what's the unbiased ranking in ur mind?

too much bias

-- by 会员 kndx5 (2010/11/28 1:36:04)

-- by 会员 fzxc613 (2010/11/29 4:05:54)

-- by 会员 kndx5 (2010/11/29 7:49:20)