OG13 CR19 关于OG答案的异议

fmcenji

19. A major network news organization experienced a drop in viewership in the week following the airing of a controversial report on the economy. The network also received a very large number of com plaints regarding the report. The network, however, maintains that negative reactions to the report had nothing to do with its loss of viewers.

Which of the following,if true, most strongly supports the network’s position?


(A) The other major network news organizations reported similar reductions in viewership during the same week.

(B) The viewers whoregistered complaints with the network were regular viewers of the newsorganization’s programs.

(C) Major network newsorganizations publicly attribute drops in viewership to their own reports onlywhen they receive complaints about those reports.

(D) This was not thefirst time that this network news organization has aired a controversial reporton the economy that has inspired viewers to complain to the network.

(E) Most network newsviewers rely on network news broadcasts as their primary source of informationregarding the economy.



电视台称不是因为播放了争议的内容才导致的下降。
以下为真，增强电视台的这个观点。

关于A选项的疑问：A说其他的电视台在此期间也播了这个争议材料---收视下降了。
OG的解释是：This statement indicates that something other than the airing of the report could accound for the subsequent drop in the organization's viewership.

但是我来推理A答案的思路是这样的：

其他家播了争议材料---下降----和你的情况一样-----说明什么？？？
其他家播了争议材料---没下降--和你的情况不一样--说明是你的问题。

按照这个思路去理解，A就不对了。你播了争议材料，结果下降，别人家播了，也下降，说明你们俩播的材料有问题，这还有什么好说的？

接下来，你播了争议材料，结果下降，别人家播了，没下降，说明还是你有问你，你播了才下降的。

反正就是你的问题，播了就下降了。


看了那么多关于此题的解释，过不了这道题的坎。我陷入了自己的怪圈当中，求解救。

alice_cd

LZ应该是把A选项看错了吧？你的怪圈有个前提，那就是其他的和这家都播了相同内容后导致下降。
但是选项是说其他的也经历了相同下降（没说是播相同的内容），也就是说这个report不是下降的原因，所以不理他。