再三求解一道逻辑题

ericwilliam

Ordinary mountain sickness, a common condition among mountain climbers, and one from which most people can recover, is caused by the characteristic shortage of oxygen in the atmosphere at high altitudes. Cerebral edema, a rarer disruption of blood circulation in the brain that quickly becomes life-threatening if not correctly treated from its onset, can also be caused by a shortage of oxygen. Since the symptoms of cerebral edema resemble those of ordinary mountain sickness, cerebral edema is especially dangerous at high altitudes.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
(A) The treatment for ordinary mountain sickness differs from the treatment for cerebral edema.
(B) Cerebral edema can cause those who suffer from it to slip into a coma within a few hours.
(C) Unlike cerebral edema, ordinary mountain sickness involves no disruption of blood circulation in the brain.
(D) Shortage of oxygen at extremely high altitude is likely to affect thinking processes and cause errors of judgment.(E) Most people who suffer from ordinary mountain sickness recover without any special treatment.
答案是E,可是A为什么不对呢？（我的理由是：因为两种症候cerebral和ordinary mountain sickness很像，所以cerebral edema很可能用ordinary mountain sickness来治，从而耽误了治疗时间，所以cerebral edema 很危险。）

cdwayne

答案是(A)

ericwilliam

不是的，我查了答案是E

cdwayne

這是LSAT的題，答案是(A)，你自己的推導難道不對嗎？

小MMM

高海拔低氧，造成爬山病，很普遍可以好。CE这个病可致死，也由缺氧造成。CE和爬山病的症状很像，所以CE在高海拔时尤其危险。找假设。
类比型。原文隐藏的是，爬山病在高海拔不危险。那我要说的其实是，二者不同，二者不类似。A很直接说二者differ。
A，取非，如果治疗CE和治疗爬山病的方法一样，那么在高海拔得了CE就直接用爬山病的方法治疗，就不会especially dangerous了。否定了结论。正确答案。
错选：觉得treatment是无关选项。
备注：什么叫especially dangerous？就是救不活，那么就应该自然而然想到选项会说治疗方法。