OG10-CR204 如果按照GWD的方法理解，如何排除C选项

长也

og10-204

[size=1em]11版verbal的81题 [size=1em] An eyeglass manufacturer tried to boost sales for the summer quarter by offering its distributors a special discount if their orders for that quarter exceeded those for last year's summer quarter by at least 20 percent．Many distributors qualified for this discount．Even with much merchandise discounted，sales increased enough to produce a healthy gain in net profits．The manufacturer plans to repeat this success by offering the same sort of discount for the fall quarter． [size=1em]Which of the following，if true，most clearly points to a flaw in the manufacturer's plan to repeat the successful performance of the summer quarter? [size=1em](A)  In general, a distributor's orders for the summer quarter are no higher than those for the spring quarter． [size=1em](B)  Along with offering special discounts to qualifying distributors，the manufacturer increased newspaper and radio advertising in those distributors’ sales areas． [size=1em](C)  The distributors most likely to qualify for the manufacturer's special discount are those whose orders were unusually low a year earlier. [size=1em](D)  The distributors who qualified for the manufacturer's special discount were free to decide how much of that discount to pass on to their own customers． [size=1em](E)  The distributors’ ordering more goods in the summer quarter left them overstocked for the fall quarter [size=1em]就我看了GWD的CR网课（应该是比较近几年的），用的是他所说的题干是老板提问题，题目是员工与老板谈论问题的方法，想用这道题实践一下（因为他在网课里顺口提到了这道题）。排除完后只剩C和E，自己通过感觉和猜测选了E，但我很想知道如果是运用GWD的方法，是如何认为C错的？如果有其他好的解释也可以。谢谢大家了！

kluivert

不了解gwd的东东
说下俺的理解
(C)  The distributors most likely to qualify for the manufacturer's special discount are those whose orders were unusually low a year earlier.
这选项没毛病，你去年低是你的事，只要你多下订单就ok,工厂只在乎多订单

如果这个选项加个条件就不一样了 only in the summer of last year

那就意味着针对于summer的措施有效是因为distributor一年前的summer生意太差order太低，今年summer生意正常，order很正常比去年多,并不是制造商的打折措施有效。 因为销售差only in the summer of last year ，所以一年前的fall, distributor的生意正常。用同样的措施就会打问号了

CoralUT

题目读完感觉就是某某制造商在夏天的时候给了个打折啥的，然后什么自己的增加，然后就想秋天也这样搞。
这是一道驳斥题，可以当作说话类来做，首先看理没理，再看是不是让老板不爽
AB很明显无关，可以直接排处，
CD都是说这些 distributors 是怎么样的 distributors，你老板说我想给一个夏天一样的折扣，这样销售就增加了。你说这些人去年的时候订单都很少巴拉巴拉。
去年发生的事情和今年没啥太大关联啊，老板和你说折扣方式，你跟老板聊这些人怎么样，我估计老板会问一句：“所以呢？”
就，你懂吧，感觉不是一件事情，因为你拿到选项的时候必须要客观，所以不能做多余的推测，你在往下推断的过程中会加入额外主观信息，这违背了客观原则。
再体会一下E选项，首先E感觉是围绕订单多少来说的，题目本身也和订单有关，且E选项表达的含义就是：夏天订单多了导致过多库存在秋天，言下之意就是老板，他们不会增加秋天的订单啊。这不是我推断的，而是选项本身的含义，如果非要杠，为什么秋天就不增加订单了我一样可以多订一点明年卖啊，这题就没法做了。
2楼解释也很赞，但是我想起打脑壳

CoralUT

CoralUT 发表于 2018-10-28 09:31
题目读完感觉就是某某制造商在夏天的时候给了个打折啥的，然后什么自己的增加，然后就想秋天也这样搞。
这 ...

不不不，我想了一下，2楼解释也有问题啊，凭啥去年秋天正常，就意味着今年秋天正常了。这也算是主观推测了吧，虽然我懂2楼的意思。