求助 大全上的gmat题

lisiberry

In an effort to go beyond resumes as tools in its search for executives, one leading company has resorted to interviewing the top candidates for a position all together in a single group. This technique is supposed to afford a direct comparison of the candidates with respect to some personal qualities that cannot be gleaned from a resume.
Which of the following, if true, casts the most serious doubt on the value of the simultaneous interview technique?

(A) Resumes do sometimes allow reliable inferences to be made about a candidate’s personal qualities.
(B) The simultaneous interview could become cumbersome if there were a great many candidates for a position.
(C) The more perceptive the interviewer, the more revealing the simultaneous interview is apt to be.
(D) There are certain personal qualities that only an extended simultaneous interview can bring out.
(E) The simultaneous interview distorts each candidate’s response style by inducing stresses unlike any an executive position induces.

OA E

我选B，请问一下为什么B错呢？

sheanen

之前有人討論過 幫你節錄下來

B确实说了simultaneous interview的不好，但是没有weaken结论，因为结论并不是笼统说simultaneous interview比一般的要好，而是focus于with respect to some personal qualities that cannot be gleaned from a resume.E直接说了simultaneous interview会歪曲应聘者的反映，所以结论所说的some personal qualities是不能从中准确得出的。

出自 http://forum.chasedream.com/thread-367515-1-1.html

RRZZR

题目我觉得已经说supposed to，也就意味着"this technique, if implemented, afford a direct comparison..."所以根本就不考虑implement麻烦不麻烦(cumbersome or not)的情况

lisiberry

sheanen 发表于 2017-2-27 23:59
之前有人討論過 幫你節錄下來

B确实说了simultaneous interview的不好，但是没有weaken结论，因为结论并不 ...

明白了，谢谢。
还是审题不认真呀

lisiberry

RRZZR 发表于 2017-2-28 13:03
题目我觉得已经说supposed to，也就意味着"this technique, if implemented, afford a direct comparison.. ...

谢谢RRZZR又来帮忙。

即使implemented, 还是有可能因为麻烦而导致失败吧。
相对，觉得楼上说的，本题说的不是笼统说simultaneous interview比一般的要好，而是focus于with respect to some personal qualities that cannot be gleaned from a resume. 这个观点的话可以直接解题。

RRZZR

lisiberry 发表于 2017-2-28 13:56
谢谢RRZZR又来帮忙。

即使implemented, 还是有可能因为麻烦而导致失败吧。

也是，我上面的解释方法是有问题。