求助一道逻辑JJ~

wsyzzydy

Doctor: Research shows that adolescents who play video games on a regular basis are three times as likely to develop carpal tunnel syndrome as are adolescents who do not play video games. Federal legislation that prohibits the sale of video games to minors would help curb this painful wrist condition among adolescents.
The doctor’s conclusion depends on which of the following assumptions?

A The majority of federal legislators would vote for a bill that prohibits the sale of video games to minors.
B Not all adolescents who play video games on a regular basis suffer from carpal tunnel syndrome.
C Playing video games is the only way an adolescent can develop carpal tunnel syndrome.
D Most parents would refuse to purchase video games for their adolescent children
E The regular playing of video games by adolescents does not produce such beneficial effects as better hand-eye coordination and improved reaction time.
正确答案：D（非常非常确定，小心变体）



谁能帮我讲下为什么选D~C又为什么不对呢？？

xp1231

http://www.manhattangmat.com/forums/mgmat-cr-doctor-research-shows-that-adolescents-who-play-t2445.html

-- by 会员 tingting85114 (2012/2/13 10:35:13)

ron大神说的很好。

kiddinsh

Doctor: Research shows that adolescents who play video games on a regular basis are three times as likely to develop carpal tunnel syndrome as are adolescents who do not play video games. Federal legislation that prohibits the sale of video games to minors would help curb this painful wrist condition among adolescents.
The doctor’s conclusion depends on which of the following assumptions?

A The majority of federal legislators would vote for a bill that prohibits the sale of video games to minors.
B Not all adolescents who play video games on a regular basis suffer from carpal tunnel syndrome.
C Playing video games is the only way an adolescent can develop carpal tunnel syndrome.
D Most parents would refuse to purchase video games for their adolescent children
E The regular playing of video games by adolescents does not produce such beneficial effects as better hand-eye coordination and improved reaction time.
正确答案：D（非常非常确定，小心变体）



谁能帮我讲下为什么选D~C又为什么不对呢？？

-- by 会员 wsyzzydy (2012/2/13 9:33:31)

lawyer里面典型的否定它因
假设题常用的两种做法
1.弥补推理gap
2.否定它因，就是否定题目条件之外会对结论有影响的条件，选项里一般会出现否定词，比如not, no等-gwd里面这种很多哈

-- by 会员 kiddinsh (2012/2/13 10:50:20)

请教一下如果这题问加强的话，应该选C吗？

-- by 会员 peggy在奋斗 (2012/2/13 11:07:43)

加强和假设是一样的做法，假设也是加强的一种哈

wsyzzydy

恩~明白了~谢谢哈

wsyzzydy

恩~是这个意思啦~刚看了外国帖子也是怎么说的~答案是D

peggy在奋斗

Doctor: Research shows that adolescents who play video games on a regular basis are three times as likely to develop carpal tunnel syndrome as are adolescents who do not play video games. Federal legislation that prohibits the sale of video games to minors would help curb this painful wrist condition among adolescents.
The doctor’s conclusion depends on which of the following assumptions?

A The majority of federal legislators would vote for a bill that prohibits the sale of video games to minors.
B Not all adolescents who play video games on a regular basis suffer from carpal tunnel syndrome.
C Playing video games is the only way an adolescent can develop carpal tunnel syndrome.
D Most parents would refuse to purchase video games for their adolescent children
E The regular playing of video games by adolescents does not produce such beneficial effects as better hand-eye coordination and improved reaction time.
正确答案：D（非常非常确定，小心变体）



谁能帮我讲下为什么选D~C又为什么不对呢？？

-- by 会员 wsyzzydy (2012/2/13 9:33:31)

lawyer里面典型的否定它因
假设题常用的两种做法
1.弥补推理gap
2.否定它因，就是否定题目条件之外会对结论有影响的条件，选项里一般会出现否定词，比如not, no等-gwd里面这种很多哈

-- by 会员 kiddinsh (2012/2/13 10:50:20)

请教一下如果这题问加强的话，应该选C吗？

kiddinsh

Doctor: Research shows that adolescents who play video games on a regular basis are three times as likely to develop carpal tunnel syndrome as are adolescents who do not play video games. Federal legislation that prohibits the sale of video games to minors would help curb this painful wrist condition among adolescents.
The doctor’s conclusion depends on which of the following assumptions?

A The majority of federal legislators would vote for a bill that prohibits the sale of video games to minors.
B Not all adolescents who play video games on a regular basis suffer from carpal tunnel syndrome.
C Playing video games is the only way an adolescent can develop carpal tunnel syndrome.
D Most parents would refuse to purchase video games for their adolescent children
E The regular playing of video games by adolescents does not produce such beneficial effects as better hand-eye coordination and improved reaction time.
正确答案：D（非常非常确定，小心变体）



谁能帮我讲下为什么选D~C又为什么不对呢？？

-- by 会员 wsyzzydy (2012/2/13 9:33:31)

lawyer里面典型的否定它因
假设题常用的两种做法
1.弥补推理gap
2.否定它因，就是否定题目条件之外会对结论有影响的条件，选项里一般会出现否定词，比如not, no等-gwd里面这种很多哈

tingting85114

我觉得D是正确的。
首先这题是问的是Assumption。Research 说玩游戏的青少年are three times as likely to develop carpal tunnel syndrome as are adolescents who do not play video games. 于是就说如果Federal legislation 禁止了游戏的销售的话，那么Federal legislation that prohibits the sale of video games to minors would help curb this painful wrist condition among adolescents. 我觉得关键是那个minors。如果minors不能买，但是他们的家人仍然买给他们的话，那么那个legislation就没效果了，而carpal tunnel syndrome也一样不会减少。所以，只有那个minors的家长refuse to purchase video games for their adolescent children，才可以help curb this painful wrist condition among adolescents. 我个人的理解，不知道对不对哦~

GT`crayon

这是哪里的一道题啊……答案到底是C还是D……额怎么觉着D对呢

tingting85114

http://www.manhattangmat.com/forums/mgmat-cr-doctor-research-shows-that-adolescents-who-play-t2445.html