纠结了好久manhattan的一道逻辑题~~求NN解惑~~~

若雪

A recent article asserted that, from 2002 to 2006, Band 1 generated the most revenue of any band in the world. The article based this claim on the fact that in each of those years, Band 1 sold the most albums, and Band 1's highly anticipated first concert tour was the highest grossing concert tour in the industry in 2006.
Which of the following, if true, weakens the article's assertion?

A. The band with the highest grossing tour in the industry in 2002 did not tour again in the next four years.
B. Band 1 typically puts on extraordinarily expensive concerts with elaborate staging, video displays and light shows.
C. From 2002 to 2006, other bands released concert film and video anthology DVDs that were extremely lucrative.
D. All of Band 1's albums released from 2002 to 2006 were poorly received by the music industry.
E. Internet piracy of music resulted in depressed album sales for the period 2002 to 2006 relative to earlier years.

我选了B，答案是C。
我觉得B的话说明虽然band1收入高但是花费也高所以不一定利润最高
C的话我觉得就算别人有其他收入那也未必会高于BAND1啊。
纠结了好久。。。求NN解惑~~


谢谢~~鞠躬~~~

sdcar2010

[quote]
c的release是什么意思啊？

-- by 会员 rainbowmanutd (2011/6/18 15:10:42)

[/quote

发布，发行

rainbowmanutd

c的release是什么意思啊？

camelo777

恩恩这个挺容易犯的，记住要抓住原文结论的特殊性，是profit就不能是别的~
我24号考~大家一起加油
：）

若雪

首先同学下次你最好把字体放大点哈》。。看得我好费劲。
就像你自己说的B说的是利润不一定最高，但是题目中没有提到利润，只是说band1的收入最高，这样B就起不到削弱的作用。

反观C，确实别人就算有其他收入也不一定高于band 1，但是注意C的用词extremely lucrative，这种语气强烈的词是应该引起你重视的。

因为是极其高，所以原文的claim"Band 1 generated the most revenue of any band in the world."就被削弱了。

说实话这道题我第一眼可能也不会选C，但是通过排除法很容易得到C就是答案。

-- by 会员 camelo777 (2011/6/15 7:31:52)

谢谢提醒~~马上改正~~~
欧~~原来是这样。。。谢谢~~~下次会多注意极端词的
PS：我犯了个很弱的错误。。我把revenue看成了Profit。。。咳咳。。。PS2：你快要考G了么？~加油！

camelo777

首先同学下次你最好把字体放大点哈》。。看得我好费劲。
就像你自己说的B说的是利润不一定最高，但是题目中没有提到利润，只是说band1的收入最高，这样B就起不到削弱的作用。

反观C，确实别人就算有其他收入也不一定高于band 1，但是注意C的用词extremely lucrative，这种语气强烈的词是应该引起你重视的。

因为是极其高，所以原文的claim"Band 1 generated the most revenue of any band in the world."就被削弱了。

说实话这道题我第一眼可能也不会选C，但是通过排除法很容易得到C就是答案。