GMAT 逻辑分析题 (11)

sdcar2010

A Beijingnese perceives sentences of his own dialect as sequences of well-articulated words. But this perception cannot be accurate. This is demonstrated by the fact that a Hunanese tourist, who does not know the Beijing dialect, only hears an incomprehensible, continuous stream of sound, not sentences with intelligible words, voiced by Beijingnese around him.

Which one of the following is an assumption on which the above argument depends?

(A) It is impossible to understand a sentence if the sentence is simply a continuous stream of sound.
(B) Those Hunanese who do not know the Beijing dialect cannot hear the correct way in which the Beijing dialect actually sounds.
(C) A person pays less attention to the way his own dialect sounds than he does to the way another unfamiliar dialect sounds.
(D) An educated Hunanese who studies the Beijing dialect does not perceive sentences in the Beijing dialect as a continuous stream of sound.
(E) The perception of a Beijingnese of his dialect is not more accurate than is the perception of a Hunanese who knows nothing about the Beijing dialect.

yxlalala

假设题本质是加强，b选项有点削弱意思，把b取反即湖南人与北京人听到的北京方言是一样的correct way，就说明确实北京dialect well-articulated不对，与文中结论：北京人认为自己方言well-articulated这个认识错误，相同。并不削弱原有结论，所以b应该是错的

单挑谁怕谁

楼主你的头像真好看

livebelieve

看不懂意思要快速判断的时候，我会找出关键词两个，然后在答案搜索有这两个关键词的句子。。。

单调唱

选E，很简单。如果否定E，我们就不能通过湖南人对北京话的感觉推出北京人的perception是不准确的。

clover_duan

总觉得该选B，求本题的分析和推理链……

sdcar2010

Why don't you negate the answer choices and see which one would make the conclusion fall apart.

在B和E中犹豫= =…………求解释…………

-- by 会员 引夕 (2011/10/18 14:04:39)

引夕

在B和E中犹豫= =…………求解释…………

sdcar2010

Kevin is right.  Again!

kevin0214

我选E，这是道好题。值得一看。