GMAT 逻辑分析题 (5)

sdcar2010

When people submit their posts to ChaseDream.com, their intentions cannot be more bad than good.Otherwise, as members of a close-knit on-line community, we would stop trusting each other. However, no on-line community, ChaseDream.com included, can survive without mutual trust among its members.

The argument is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?

(A) It neglects the possibility that a true belief can have unexpected harmful consequences.

(B) It mistakenly assumes that if two different claims cannot be true at the same time, then both claims cannot be false at the same time.

(C) It questions the validity of a claim by calling into question the intentions of those who make the claim.

(D) It assumes without justification that whenever two possible outcomes are possible, inevitably the more negative one will occur.

(E) It gives no reason to believe that a statement that is true of a given online community is also true of any other online community.

livebelieve

这种就是要找前提假设的题目，估计是GMAT里最难的。。。。因为它只给了因果推理过程给你，你要在因里面找前提

livebelieve

那个however后面那句话真的不知道在这题有什么作用。全句的意思是，人们在CD上上传答案的目的不能恶意多于善意。否则，人们就不能继续相信CD。CD的存在需要相互信任为基础。然后楼主问哪个选项对结论有weaken。A的意思是 ：信任可能会导致悲剧（ true belief就是trust的意思）


W HAT THE f*

livebelieve

能不能用中文讲解下。。。。。。。

DQStephanie

想了半天还是没怎么懂啊
原文作者是想通过chasedream.com still survive --> people don't stop trusting each other --> more good than bad.
看大神分析说：even if more good than bad, there will still be some bad consequences.
但原文里表达的意思是no bad consequences (since online community still survive) so more good than bad. 感觉和上面没有什么关系诶。。。
想知道我的逻辑哪里错了。

yaomincui

Thanks a lot. I think I should analyze the passage more carefully.
I try to read the English newspaper once a day, but I find myself cannot understand the passage very well. After reading, I will spend much time to check the sentences and words I do not know in the dictionary. It takes me a lot of time.
Help! Am I on the right way to improve my reading?

单调唱

这道题理解了好一会儿~~学习了~！

sdcar2010

I believe it is a premise.

请问SDCAR，这句话在argument中是什么作用？THX！

However, no on-line community, ChaseDream.com included, can survive without mutual trust among its members.

-- by 会员 nobody910 (2012/2/5 16:10:22)

nobody910

请问SDCAR，这句话在argument中是什么作用？THX！

However, no on-line community, ChaseDream.com included, can survive without mutual trust among its members.

monalisa0421

看了好久才看懂呢。。。学习了！！