逻辑狗第九 戒烟药

zmy19880908

第九题 感觉像prep里面的一题

麻烦考完的同学确认确认啊~~~

84.    (24641-!-item-!-188;#058&001146)

In Borania many people who want to quit smoking wear nicotine skin patches, which deliver small doses of nicotine through the skin.  Beginning next month, these patches can be purchased without a doctor's prescription.  Although nonprescription patches will be no more effective than those obtained by prescription and will be equally expensive, patch manufacturers are nevertheless predicting that the patches' new nonprescription status will boost sales, which have slowed considerably in recent years.

Which of the following, if true in Borania, most strongly supports the manufacturers' prediction?

A. Most people who wanted to quit smoking and who found the nicotine skin patch helpful in quitting have quit.
B. Nicotine skin patches generally cost more to use than do other types of aids that help people to quit smoking.
C. Several nonprescription aids aimed at helping people to quit smoking have been widely available for a number of years.
D. Many smokers who want to quit smoking feel that they cannot afford to visit a doctor for a prescription.
E. People who use nicotine skin patches have approximately the same rate of success in quitting smoking as do people who use other aids aimed at helping people to quit smoking.

Prep 给的答案是D
不过我很有疑问，不是已经说了“nonprescription patches will be no more effective than those obtained by prescription ”
难道是看医生还有很多额外费用，现在变非处方药就只需要付药钱吗？？

lamandel

6.一个戒烟的药：
背景说一种药叫做n什么的，它是将nicotine通过皮肤上来patch（反正就是它的作用机制之类的），然后现在它改为了nonprescrition的药，它在非处方柜台就可以买到了，而市面上面还有一种药，叫freesmoker，它必须通过perscription才能够买到。并且，第一次的n这种药比freesmoker还要便宜，因此n的销量会上升，freesmoker销量会下降。问support。
1.  去年，n一次价格下降之后，n销量上升，freesmoker的销量下降。
2.   市面上还有其他的这样的药
3.   你们为了减少开支，可以不服用这种药，去用其他的一些戒烟的方式，
其他的忘了
这是我寂静里头写的哈  简单哈 其他用无关很好排除 不怕不怕

zmy19880908

我考的这一题，gmac把题给改了 只有前两句是一样的  后面就具体讲了两个patch的品牌

-- by 会员 lamandel (2010/10/24 19:59:55)

谢谢ls 的同学

serenashu

LS能在说详细点吗？那问题什么的呢？tricky吗？

lamandel

我考的这一题，gmac把题给改了 只有前两句是一样的  后面就具体讲了两个patch的品牌

zmy19880908

答案D是对的吧，去看医生的话，要收诊断费挂号费神马的吧~~

-- by 会员 serenashu (2010/10/24 17:46:58)

不是总说做逻辑不要凭自己的经验和主观判断嘛。。 难道这种common sense 就可以自己加??

-- by 会员 zmy19880908 (2010/10/24 18:03:07)

但是其他的答案都没这个靠谱吧~~~

-- by 会员 serenashu (2010/10/24 19:02:11)

那是的，当初排除法也只能选这个，但是这题和jj里题目问的确实不一样，到时候好好审题啊~~

serenashu

答案D是对的吧，去看医生的话，要收诊断费挂号费神马的吧~~

-- by 会员 serenashu (2010/10/24 17:46:58)

不是总说做逻辑不要凭自己的经验和主观判断嘛。。 难道这种common sense 就可以自己加??

-- by 会员 zmy19880908 (2010/10/24 18:03:07)

但是其他的答案都没这个靠谱吧~~~

zmy19880908

估计是10月份jj 拖得太长，让本来现在考的战友数量大减，导致大家格外团结吧。。
嘿嘿

cutewen

感觉。。这回11月的筒子们都特别给力啊！~~~ 这才考了两三天 考古的嗖嗖的出~~

zmy19880908

答案D是对的吧，去看医生的话，要收诊断费挂号费神马的吧~~

-- by 会员 serenashu (2010/10/24 17:46:58)

不是总说做逻辑不要凭自己的经验和主观判断嘛。。 难道这种common sense 就可以自己加??