求助 OG12- CR88

bdsjb116

88. Businesses are suffering because of a lack of money available for development loans. To help businesses, the government plans to modify the income-tax structure in order to induce individual taxpayers to put a larger portion of their incomes into retirement savings accounts, because as more money is deposited in such accounts, more money becomesavailable to borrowers.
Which of the following, if true, raises the most serious doubt regarding the effectiveness of the government’s plan to increase the amount of money available for development loans for businesses?
(A) When levels of personal retirement savings increase, consumer borrowing always increases correspondingly.
(B) The increased tax revenue the government would receive as a result of business expansion would not offset the loss in revenue from personal income taxes during the first year of the plan.
(C) Even with tax incentives, some people will choose not to increase their levels of retirement savings.
(D) Bankers generally will not continue to lend money to businesses whose prospective earnings are insufficient to meet their loan repayment schedules.
(E) The modified tax structure would give all taxpayers, regardless of their incomes, the same tax savings for a given increase in their retirement savings.

答案是A 可D为什么不对呢?

cdbgin009

gourmettsu 发表于 2011-7-22 19:41
我觉得A、C都能weaken啊！！

C只能说不借loans，而不能说没有loans。无关

qzawxs9876

谁能告诉我OG 对D选项的解释是什么意思？
D The plan would increase the money available specifically for development loans ,not existing loans.

ringo5

jay871750293 发表于 2012-2-24 16:34
看了之前的一些观点，深有启发，也来写写我的想法，关于A&C，比较两者谁的影响更大，影响最大的，则是题目 ...

可是A选项也存在说 一方面增加一方面减少，而减少的没有增加的多，所以总量仍然增加的可能性啊。为什么不提到这个呢~~

也就是说A选项其实存在三种可能，
1.增加>减少，总量增加，support
2.增加=减少，总量不变，weaken
3.增加<减少，总量减少，weaken

个人觉得A选项并不怎么好，因为几种可能性的存在并不能确定到底是怎样。
但其他选项错误比较明显。

MissUindeed

答案需要对症下药，不然即使言之有物也是无关选项。

wilincl9321

我明白B选项是无关选项，可是我不明白他的实际（非字面上的)意思，有那位好心人帮忙解释一下？谢谢！
(B) The increased tax revenue the government would receive as a result of business expansion would not offset the loss in revenue from personal income taxes during the first year of the plan.====

qiuhua01234567

你们没看见C里面的some 么？这是典型错误，读题的时候一定要注意限定词。shell game

sunny20111126

C项，Some people 不足以影响the total amount deposited,og 说得很明白啊

宇多田光

在CR BIBLE里有提到，weaken的其中一种打击对象是premise,但通常GMAT不从这里出考点，是外国的GMAT考试专家在书中提到的，所以我们也可以认为反驳了premise，应该不是正确答案。

jay871750293

看了之前的一些观点，深有启发，也来写写我的想法，

关于A&C，比较两者谁的影响更大，影响最大的，则是题目所说“raises the most serious doubt”
先来看C，some people choose not increase their levels of retirement savings，虽然有些人不愿意存钱，但总有人会存，那么存钱的数量肯定是会增加的（只不过没有预想的那么多而已）
再来看A，consumer's level of saving and borrowing will increase correspondingly，存钱数量在增加的同时也在减少，但是并没有说增加和减少的数量，那么完全有可能增加和减少的数量一样多或者是减少的数量大于增加的数量，存钱的数量可能不会变，甚至可能减少，所以A的影响比C更大，所以选A

希望能对曾经和我一样迷茫的CDer有帮助~~~