求救 GWD25-Q5 答案有问题

sbwhhnybz

GWD25-Q5.
For many revisionist historians, Christopher Columbus has come to personify devastation and enslavement in the name of progress that has decimated native peoples of the Western Hemisphere.


A. devastation and enslavement in the name of progress that has decimated native peoples of the Western Hemisphere
B. devastation and enslavement in the name of progress by which native peoples of the Western Hemisphere decimated
C. devastating and enslaving in the name of progress those native peoples of the Western Hemisphere which in the name of progress are decimated.
D. devastating and enslaving those native peoples of the western Hemisphere which in the name of progress are decimated.
E. the devastation and enslavement in the name of progress that have decimated the native peoples of the Western Hemisphere.


讨论答案是A，但是google了一下，native 都选的是E。


请问各位大牛 到底是A还是E啊？


谢谢！

Alaska17

是E啦。但我不明白这句为什么不写成：
For many revisionist historians, Christopher Columbus has, in the name of progress, come to personify devastation and enslavement that have decimated native peoples of the Western Hemisphere.

阿丹考GMAT

醒醒Shine 发表于 2014-4-25 12:05
1、the devastation and enslavements是一个整体，后面是process不是processes。肯定用 单数 Verb。
2、没 ...

哈哈哈哈哈哈

醒醒Shine

1、the devastation and enslavements是一个整体，后面是process不是processes。肯定用 单数 Verb。
2、没有必要的时候，不要 乱用 discontinuous modifier。
3、that修饰the devastation and enslavements, 极为awkward, 重复的一塌糊涂。
看到的一个解释，觉得更有道理。

justeva

但是LS们，如果E的话，have是必然错的呀，必须是has单数，这怎么解释

briarbaby

我觉得也是E....开始选B 就是觉得人才是decimate的发起者，后来再看看，觉得就只能是， CC has become to personify the D and E in the name of progress that have demated .....

这里personify 的用法：
We often personify the sun and the moon, calling the sun “he” and the moon “she”.
我们经常用“他”来称呼太阳, 用“她”来称呼月亮, 使他们人格化。

personify the D and E in the name of progress
以发展的名义来美化D/E that实际上却杀死了很多人

-- by 会员 Poodle1223 (2011/2/6 0:12:08)

ls 解释的很好~就是E~

Poodle1223

我觉得也是E....开始选B 就是觉得人才是decimate的发起者，后来再看看，觉得就只能是， CC has become to personify the D and E in the name of progress that have demated .....

这里personify 的用法：
We often personify the sun and the moon, calling the sun “he” and the moon “she”.
我们经常用“他”来称呼太阳, 用“她”来称呼月亮, 使他们人格化。

personify the D and E in the name of progress
以发展的名义来美化D/E that实际上却杀死了很多人

sataharu

根据句子意思，我觉得That好像没必要吧，以为progress不可能HAS decimated native peoples，意思就完全错了，所以必须是devastation and enslavement have ecimated native peoples，这样that去掉读起来是不是比较顺啊

-- by 会员 chris5105077 (2010/8/30 15:11:11)

我感觉也是progress 不能decimate额

chris5105077

根据句子意思，我觉得That好像没必要吧，以为progress不可能HAS decimated native peoples，意思就完全错了，所以必须是devastation and enslavement have ecimated native peoples，这样that去掉读起来是不是比较顺啊

zcool

个人还是觉得A，如果that指代前面的devastation and enslavement，那么in the process 又是什么意思的，这样这个机构就是多余的，显然that指代process，personify是“是。。。的化身”的意思。
共参考