请教GWD-TN24-22-Q22

zzchris

The sense of delayed gratification, of working now for later pleasure, has helped shape the economic behavior of our society. However, that sense is no longer nurtured as consistently in our children as it once was. For example, it used to take a bit of patience to put together the toys that children got in cereal boxes; now the toys come from the boxes whole.
Which of the following is an assumption of the passage above?

A.The toys in cereal boxes have changed partly because the economic conditions of our society have improved.
B.The influence of promotion gimmicks on the economic behavior of our society has increased over the years.
C.The toys that used to come in cereal boxes were put together by the same children who played with them.
D.Part of the pleasure of any toy lie in putting the toy together before playing with it.
E.Today's children do not expect a single toy to provide pleasure for a long period of time.

答案是C，但我不明白D为何不对，是不是D中的lie是一般现在时，所以和文意相反，如果是过去时就对了？请教大大们，小弟不胜感激！

yoshimihoku

这个题目主要是说之前在经济社会中,人们通过劳动,最后得到奖励
C选项是符合这个要求,因为如果PUT的儿童和PLAY的儿童不是一批儿童,就不能符合最开始提出的观点
D选项说玩的过程中有乐趣,这个跟题目主要思想不符,题目是说,做了才有收获,D是说做的同时就有收获
E无关

-- by 会员 Rebeldom (2010/5/11 11:49:25)

Part of the pleasure of any toy lie in putting the toy together before playing with it.

D说的是在玩前，把他们放到一起，会让人pleasure，并不是“做的同时就有收获”，所以我觉得D好像还是有关的呀，怎么会无关呢？

Rebeldom

互相帮助

zzchris

谢谢Rebeldom,解释的很清楚

Rebeldom

这个题目主要是说之前在经济社会中,人们通过劳动,最后得到奖励
C选项是符合这个要求,因为如果PUT的儿童和PLAY的儿童不是一批儿童,就不能符合最开始提出的观点
D选项说玩的过程中有乐趣,这个跟题目主要思想不符,题目是说,做了才有收获,D是说做的同时就有收获
E无关

zzchris

但GWD上答案是C的呀，我也选了D，我也是像LS一样觉得不会搞语法。但是看了答案觉得C解释了一个gap，就是以前的children并不是有些喜欢put toys together,有些喜欢play with it,而是喜欢自己put完了再play，这样才能证明是working now for later pleasure。
而D项说现在还有这种pleasure,代入原文，无法推出文章所说that sense is no longer nurtured as consistently in our children as it once was，所以我觉得D应该不对。
一点拙见，继续等牛牛...

ericphantom

先说一句啊，我不是NN，一战也很低。不过我觉得逻辑题应该不用看那么多的语法部分吧。题中是有一个gap的，也就是 put together toys 和toys come from the boxes ，用这两种行为来解释pleasure。C选项重点是说玩具，而题目中的结论是直接点到pleasure, 也就是说举出的两个例子应该是支持pleasure的.所以考虑相关Pleasure的话只有DE选项，而E选项中的single toy又与原文无关，所以我觉得应该是D。
一点愚见，等着NN补充

zzchris

自己顶，有没有人帮帮我啊....