chicago和columbia那个好？

wordance

等待的无聊，大家来讨论一下这两个传统金融牛校吧。
Chicago:
Pro: 世界上最强的faculty. 几乎是芝加哥开创了当代金融。从academics上讲，不做第二人选
Con: 有reputation说chicago 学生相对nerdy和clumsy一点，不知道是不是真的。
Columbia:
Pro: NYC.
Con: 似乎没有什么明显弱点？

大家发表一下意见吧。如果要你选一个去读，你会选哪一个？为什么？

redstudent

都好！

wyf815767690

yidiyuehan

先拿到一个再讨论吧.....

fengerjin

CBS在美国人心里和Chicago Booth不是peer schools，要差一截的... 所谓M7是老印在BW论坛上炮制出来的。momentum也是Booth好一点

不过很多人会给CBS的location加分，所以看你自己value什么吧。Greater China Alum方面Booth要稍好些

-- by 会员 attract (2009/12/16 14:00:36)

我倒是觉得两个学校商学院差不多吧，M7中除了HSW算第一层次外，剩下的也都差不多了。再说了，从整个学校的reputation来说，哥大还是略强于Chicago的，毕竟是ivy。

简而言之，两个学校都很好，也都差别不大。哥大的花销更大，但是纽约也比芝加哥更繁华。chicago更有学术气质，更适合喜欢校园文化，喜欢大学生活的人。

btw，Chicago的夏天真是太美了，密歇根湖和城里紧凑的高层建筑，真是相印成趣。纽约是繁华，但是真的没有觉得有多美，乱七八糟的建筑到处都是，呵呵。

HaoBinfen

。。。

windboy

both are great schools and will get you interview opportunites. In the end, it all depends on your performance in the interviews.

in terms of finance training, chicago is probably the best, compared to other MBA programmes, if not the MFEs.

The best thing about Chicago is its flexibility as you will be able to take whatever courses you want, after while satisfying degree requirments.

For S&T, Chicago is the best of all b-schools, even better than MFE/CF/FM programmes. For IM/IB, Chicago and CBS are on par. The bottom line is that what skills/assets/network you can bring to the business. Chicago offers you quantitative finance/economic skills, which are probably the most important thing when I evaluate a grad rotating on my desk. The CBS grads who get S&T offers are also good, but not as impressive as Chicago ones...

am a Chicago alumnus and now working in S&T. am not interested in trashing schools, as it is all up to you to decide which school to go. Besides, the location issue is indeed over-stated, as some one has already mentioned...

Good luck to you all.

attract

CBS在美国人心里和Chicago Booth不是peer schools，要差一截的... 所谓M7是老印在BW论坛上炮制出来的。momentum也是Booth好一点

不过很多人会给CBS的location加分，所以看你自己value什么吧。Greater China Alum方面Booth要稍好些

lvp

If you wanna do banking in USA, they are the same. Columbia is easier for you to network but Chicago is easiser for you to show commitment.
If you wanna do banking in Asia, Chicago is better. Chicago's alum are famous for helping each other.

很丑的鬼脸

...