请教一道逻辑寂静

jadezhangweiyu · 发表于 2012-2-14 21:40:19

Investment banks often have conflicting roles. They sometimes act for a client company by raising capital from other investment institutions as advantageously as possible, but their analysts also sometimes send unfavorable reports on the financial health of companies for whom they are raising capital to other clients who wish to make investments. Analyses of companies’ financial health need to be unbiased if an investment bank is to achieve long-term success.
If the statements above are true, which of the following practices, if adopted by an investment bank, would hinder its long-term success?
A. Evaluating and rewarding the bank’s analysts on the basis of recommendations made by managers who are solely engaged in raising capital for clients
B. Using reports by the investment bank’s analysts to determine how best to raise capital for a client
C. Sharing the task of raising capital for a client with other investment banks
D. Ensuring that conflicts between analysts and those who raise capital for clients are carefully mediated and resolved by impartial arbitrators
E. Monitoring the success or failure of analysts’ current predictions about how companies will perform financially, in order to determine the value of future predictions

naoyixue · 发表于 2012-2-14 22:00:24

我觉得应该a
Investment banks often have conflicting roles. They sometimes act for a client company by raising capital from other investment institutions as advantageously as possible, but their analysts also sometimes send unfavorable reports on the financial health of companies for whom they are raising capital to other clients who wish to make investments. Analyses of companies’ financial health need to be unbiased if an investment bank is to achieve long-term success.
If the statements above are true, which of the following practices, if adopted by an investment bank, would hinder its long-term success?
A. Evaluating and rewarding the bank’s analysts on the basis of recommendations made by managers who are solely engaged in raising capital for clients
评估或者奖励按照那些仅仅从事房贷贷经理的意见（因为两者有利益关系，可能导致analyst的给出的意见bias)
B. Using reports by the investment bank’s analysts to determine how best to raise capital for a client
加强长期success(因为原文说,analyst给出相应的建议）
C. Sharing the task of raising capital for a client with other investment banks
无关
D. Ensuring that conflicts between analysts and those who raise capital for clients are carefully mediated and resolved by impartial arbitrators
加强success
E. Monitoring the success or failure of analysts’ current predictions about how companies will perform financially, in order to determine the value of future predictions
增加监管机制，保证analyst有效实施

guxin7005 · 发表于 2012-2-15 18:33:00

题目是hinder阻碍 its long-term success，A项solely太极端，不和谐。。C项应该也可以促进成功的，不知二楼的无关是啥意思？其他的几项都说得通

quasimodov · 发表于 2012-2-15 18:58:59

GWD里的原题选A
3楼这种判断方法很危险太片面看见极端词就排除

guxin7005 · 发表于 2012-2-17 09:49:30

恩。。貌似我的方法有危险啊

可以看看这个
http://forum..org/viewthread.php?tid=182283

http://forum.chasedream.com/gmat_cr/thread-579714-1-6.html

http://www.manhattangmat.com/forums/investment-banking-t10031.html

感觉楼主的决心很大，相信楼主一定会考试成功的~~

onlyonyou · 发表于 2012-2-27 16:09:11

题目说:Analyses of companies’ financial health need to be UNBIASED if an investment bank is to achieve long-term success.
A就是一种biased的做法...
我是这么理解的.

hanniesu · 发表于 2015-6-17 17:45:05

https://www.manhattanprep.com/gmat/forums/investment-banking-t10031.html

在这里RON大神说正确答案应该是B！！！

felia · 发表于 2015-6-18 08:57:05

我还是觉得A would hinder。根据楼上给出的Ron的理解法，我觉得A是说根据（#1）的推荐来奖励（#2），那么（#1）会推荐的肯定是经常给出favorable评估的（#2）咯？相反，在B中，（#2）已经给出了财务健康分析，这种情况下让（#1）去极尽所能raise capital，反倒是bridges between (#1) and (#2)。各位大大怎么看？

请教一道逻辑寂静

所属分类: GMAT考试

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()