求助一道逻辑题

jingliu097 · 发表于 2015-6-5 19:08:30

Irate parent: Your request for $2000 loans to help pay your $11000 tax bill is clearly without merit. By your own admission, you have failed to repay the $6000 I advanced you to buy a car over two years ago, despite your verbal and written assurances that you would do so over that span.
Indigent Child: Though it is true that I have been unable to repay your generous auto loan, we both know that last year I was working for a charity and received no income, a decision you endorsed. This year, I have a $11000 tax bill because I received $50000 income, but all that money can easily be accouted for: I spent $9000 on rent, $6000 on utilitied and insurance, $15000 on food, $9000 on work expenses and loans to my sister, and the remaining $11000, of course, on my taxes.
The child's defense is suspect because
A. The loans the child made to his sister were unecessary, as they clealy could have been made by the irate parent.
B. The rent, utilities, insurance, food, worl expenses, loans, and tax bill do not add up to $50000.
C. If the child has allocated $11000 to the tax bell as is insinuated in the child's defenses, then a loan with which to pay the bill would be redundant.
D. The child cannot be trusted to repay any further loans supplied by the irate parent.
E. The child could arrange a payment plan with the tax authorities.
挺有意思的一道逻辑题，但是没看懂，求NN们帮助啊~
为了不让帖子沉，我无耻地使用了隐藏内容，大家原谅我~

OA: C

benjaminsandro · 发表于 2015-6-5 22:12:08

选C啊...

jingliu097 · 发表于 2015-6-6 00:04:46

benjaminsandro 发表于 2015-6-5 22:12
选C啊...

能跟我讲解一下吗？

ukyo2003 · 发表于 2015-6-6 09:06:32

求解为什么要隐藏？

ukyo2003 · 发表于 2015-6-6 09:20:32

可以说一下是那里的题吗？这一题我也是选C，理由如下：

Irate parent: Your request for $2000 loans to help pay your $11000 tax bill is clearly without merit. By your own admission, you have failed to repay the $6000 I advanced you to buy a car over two years ago, despite your verbal and written assurances that you would do so over that span.
Indigent Child: Though it is true that I have been unable to repay your generous auto loan, we both know that last year I was working for a charity and received no income, a decision you endorsed. This year, I have a $11000 tax bill because I received $50000 income, but all that money can easily be accouted for: I spent $9000 on rent, $6000 on utilitied and insurance, $15000 on food, $9000 on work expenses and loans to my sister, and the remaining $11000, of course, on my taxes.
The child's defense is suspect because
逻辑链：
家长 - 小孩要2000块没有依据。以前借你的钱没还，没有信誉。
小孩 - 反驳不还钱，因为去年没有收入。然后argue借钱的理由，50000-9000-6000-15000-9000=11000，所以需要11000交税。
削弱：11000应该是现金结余，不应该是欠款。另外一个逻辑漏洞是，小孩没有说明2000和11000的关系。

A. The loans the child made to his sister were unecessary, as they clealy could have been made by the irate parent. (引入无关信息，sisiter原文没有，loans明显是parent的和sister无关)
B. The rent, utilities, insurance, food, worl expenses, loans, and tax bill do not add up to $50000. (这种加数字的选项肯定错，考的是逻辑不是数学)
C. If the child has allocated $11000 to the tax bell as is insinuated in the child's defenses, then a loan with which to pay the bill would be redundant. (因为11000是小孩的收入，已经是入账而不是赤字，所以不应该借钱)
D. The child cannot be trusted to repay any further loans supplied by the irate parent. (cannot be trusted是对的，但是和本文的主要逻辑无关，本文讨论的是这次11000的理由是否被warrant，而且小孩也解释了为什么之前没还钱)
E. The child could arrange a payment plan with the tax authorities. (引入无关信息)

jingliu097 · 发表于 2015-6-6 10:18:11

ukyo2003 发表于 2015-6-6 09:20
可以说一下是那里的题吗？这一题我也是选C，理由如下：

Irate parent: Your request for $2000 loans to h ...

重点在income不能包括tax bill，怎么有种抠字眼的感觉？
我本来想要解释$2000的，结果选项里面没有，然后感觉所有选项都不对，C选项读起来也不通顺。

jingliu097 · 发表于 2015-6-6 10:20:18

ukyo2003 发表于 2015-6-6 09:20
可以说一下是那里的题吗？这一题我也是选C，理由如下：

Irate parent: Your request for $2000 loans to h ...

是手机软件里面的题目，我手打上去的也是蛮拼的

ukyo2003 · 发表于 2015-6-6 10:25:59

jingliu097 发表于 2015-6-6 10:18
重点在income不能包括tax bill，怎么有种抠字眼的感觉？
我本来想要解释$2000的，结果选项里面没有，然后 ...

读的不顺的往往正确

benjaminsandro · 发表于 2015-6-6 11:16:04

这个用讲？

父母：我们不想借钱帮你缴税，你上次借的还没还呢。
孩子：可以我有正当理由啊——理由一：blablabla；理由二：我的开销很正经啊，包括XXX，XXX，XXX，和缴$11000的税。

————————丫不是TM缴过税了么还来借钱？

求助一道逻辑题

所属分类: GMAT考试

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()