求助帖：prep08 cr 78 关于正确答案的解析

Margaret-09 · 发表于 2014-11-23 22:04:52

Kitchen magazine plans to license the use of itsname by a line of cookware. For amagazine, licensing the use of its name for products involves some danger,since if the products disappoint consumers, the magazine's reputation suffers,with consequent reductions in circulation and advertising. However, experts have evaluated the cookwareand found it superior to all other cookware advertised in Kitchen. Therefore, Kitchen can collect its licensingfee without endangering its other revenues.

The argument above assumes which of the following?

A. No other line of cookware is superior to that which will carry theKitchen name.

B. Kitchen will not license the use of its namefor any products other than the line of cookware.

C. Makers of cookware willnot find Kitchen a less attractive advertising vehicle because the magazine'sname is associated with a competing product.

D. Consumers who are not regular readers ofKitchen magazine will be attracted to the cookware by the Kitchen name.

E. Kitchen is one of the most prestigiouscooking-related magazines.

答案就是c
prep给的解析是：其他的厨具制造商会认为Kitchen杂志是一个没什么吸引力的杂志因为这个杂志的名字被和竞争对手的品牌联系在了一起。该选项直接涉及到了因果之间的联系问题。也就是说，就算有“因”，结论中的“果”也不一定可以达成。因为Kitchen其他的收入肯定是包括广告费的。属于CQ1：因果概括问题。

我怎么觉得解析里的翻译不对啊？原句不是说will not find kitchen 是一个没什么吸引力的杂志？！！

alice_cd · 发表于 2014-11-24 14:29:37

原文是说：当license its name时，杂志不会因为这个产品让消费者失望，从而影响到自己的收益。
题目问的是假设：即，其他竞争对手不会因为这个license就觉得这个杂志不好了。否则的话，会影响收益的。
分析当中是从反面解析的，不用太较真字面的啦

Margaret-09 · 发表于 2014-11-24 18:16:35

alice_cd 发表于 2014-11-24 14:29
原文是说：当license its name时，杂志不会因为这个产品让消费者失望，从而影响到自己的收益。
题目问的是 ...

好的，谢谢，感觉解析里面有些地方反而让我puzzle。我再去重新理解理解其他的题哈

alice_cd · 发表于 2014-11-27 17:05:46

Margaret-09 发表于 2014-11-24 18:16
好的，谢谢，感觉解析里面有些地方反而让我puzzle。我再去重新理解理解其他的题哈 ...

蒽，每个人理解和表达方式不同。那个笔记主要看看大概意思，还是自己理解啦。不必每句都看的O(∩_∩)O

侃偘 · 发表于 2016-2-15 08:35:58

我感觉逻辑笔记的答案是错的，作者把双重否定句的意思弄错了
Makers of cookware will not find Kitchen a less attractive advertising vehicle
because the magazine's name is associated with a competing product.
应该是 “cookware业者发现Kitchen杂志社还是很有影响力的传播媒介，因为Kitchen杂志被和一个有竞争力的品牌联系到了一起”
这个才是assumption，正因为有这个assumption的存在才“can collect its licensing fee without(不会) endangering its other revenues.”

求助帖：prep08 cr 78 关于正确答案的解析

所属分类: GMAT考试

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()