一道关于彩色电影与黑白电影的逻辑题，求解！

dora123 · 发表于 2014-7-19 12:54:45

[size=10.000000pt]Color-tinting of movies originally photographed inblack-and-white is inappropriate[size=10.000000pt].[size=10.000000pt]Hundreds of theoriginal artistic choices would have been madedifferently had these movies been filmed in color[size=10.000000pt].[size=10.000000pt]Lighting on the sets of these movies was arrangedto make highlights and shadows look right inblack-and-white[size=10.000000pt].

[size=10.000000pt]Which of the following claims, if substituted for theclaim about the lighting of movie sets, would lendthe same type of support to the argument above[size=10.000000pt]?[size=10.000000pt](A) An important part of what gives these movies
[size=10.000000pt]their identity is the result of the black-and-
[size=10.000000pt]white format[size=10.000000pt].
[size=10.000000pt](B) Color film would have better captured the film-
[size=10.000000pt]makers' intentions[size=10.000000pt].
[size=10.000000pt](C) Color film is superior to black-and-white film
[size=10.000000pt]for making movies[size=10.000000pt].
[size=10.000000pt](D) Makeup for the actors was applied so as to look
[size=10.000000pt]best in black-and-white films[size=10.000000pt].
[size=10.000000pt](E) The choice of black-and-white film over color

film is entirely a matter of taste.

－－－－－－

首先题目不大懂；其次逻辑关系不知从何下手。

谢谢大神们儿的指教！[size=10.000000pt]

dora123 · 发表于 2014-7-19 12:56:10

.Color-tinting of movies originally photographed in black-and-white is inappropriate.Hundreds of the original artistic choices would have been made differently had these movies been filmed in color. Lighting on the sets of these movies was arranged to make highlights and shadows look right in black-and-white.

Which of the following claims, if substituted for the claim about the lighting of movie sets, would lend the same type of support to the argument above?
(A) An important part of what gives these movies
their identity is the result of the black-and-
white format.
(B) Color film would have better captured the film-
makers' intentions.
(C) Color film is superior to black-and-white film
for making movies.
(D) Makeup for the actors was applied so as to look
best in black-and-white films.
(E) The choice of black-and-white film over color
film is entirely a matter of taste.
－－－－－－－－
不晓得为啥会有乱码，再发一次。

emmalou · 发表于 2014-7-19 15:27:41

结论：Color-tinting of movies originally photographed in black-and-white is inappropriate.（果）-现象
前提：Hundreds of the original artistic choices would have been made differently had these movies been filmed in color.（因）
Lighting on the sets of these movies was arranged to make highlights and shadows look right in black-and-white.（CQ削弱点哎此处我也分不清到底是干扰因素还是他因凑合

）
此处强调的是lighting 的作用，用于解释为什么还要用使用黑白色在电影中

所以同样的也找一个作用和 lightning一样的就可以了 D Makeup for the actors was applied so as to look
best in black-and-white films.用于解释为什么还要还要使用黑白

姑娘能帮我看看我发的逻辑帖吗嘿嘿

emmalou · 发表于 2014-7-19 15:29:15

话说这题逻辑感觉和GMAT不一样+_+

CatherineTSIM · 发表于 2014-7-19 17:49:38

应该选D吧。
答案要选一个和Lighting on the sets of these movies was arranged to make highlights and shadows look right in black-and-white.能产生一样效果的。
所以让演员也化妆就可以再黑白电影中也看的清了。

其实我不是很懂这个题的意思，不过看到substitute是替换的意思就选一个和Lighting on the sets of these movies was arranged to make highlights and shadows look right in black-and-white.能产生一样效果的就可以了

[逻辑小分队] 一道关于彩色电影与黑白电影的逻辑题，求解！

所属分类: GMAT考试

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()