以下是引用TeresaCarey在2007-4-22 14:58:00的发言:我认为,题中强调Clearly carpenters working on hotels before 1930 typically worked with more skill, care, and effort than carpenters who have worked on hotels built subsequently,要削弱原因,就用他因削弱。D The better quality of original carpentry.即说明不是carpenters的技术造成。B说能住更多人,无关。 请指正
No, I'm sorry but I think you've missed the point of this question. In this argument which says the carpenters before 1930 are better than those who in nowdays based on the performance of the architecture based on the comparison between the old hotel's delicate carpentry and the carpentry in nowdays bulding. D says this comparison is not fair one since the author attempts to compare the best remainings with the buildings in nowdays. It is not a peer to peer comparison. So D almost questioned the validation of the logical thread rather than to find out an other reason to weaken it. |