归纳题集中突破中--cxd一题请赐教

飞天猪piggy · 发表于 2006-11-21 23:28:00

请教大家(出处是陈向东书p262/40) 找了很多帖子都没找到想要的答案

40.After graduating form high school, people rarely multiply fractions or discuss ancient Rome, but they are confronted daily with decisions relating to home economics. Yet whereas mathematics and history are required courses in the high school curriculum, home economics is only an elective, and few students choose to take it.
Which of the following positions would be best supported by the considerations above?

(A) If mathematics and history were not required courses, few students would choose to take them.

(B) Whereas home economics would be the most useful subject for people facing the decisions they must make in daily life, often mathematics and history can also help them face these decisions.

(C) If it is important to teach high school students subjects that relate to decisions that will confront them in their daily lives, then home economics should be made an important part of the high school curriculum.

(D) Mathematics, history, and other courses that are not directly relevant to a person's daily life should not be a required part of the high school curriculum.

(E) Unless high schools put more emphasis on nonacademic subjects like home economics, people graduating from high school will never feel comfortable about making the decisions that will confront them in their daily lives.

答案选C, 我选了E.

请大家来讨论~

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-11-21 23:28:49编辑过]

飞天猪piggy · 发表于 2006-11-22 10:28:00

ding~

zby862001 · 发表于 2006-11-22 10:40:00

C) If it is important to teach high school students subjects that relate to decisions that will confront them in their daily lives, then home economics should be made an important part of the high school curriculum.

如果教授与生活有关的东西是重要的，那么就应该教授家庭经济。

(E) Unless high schools put more emphasis on nonacademic subjects like home economics, people graduating from high school will never feel comfortable about making the decisions that will confront them in their daily lives.

除非更重视家庭经济，否则从高中毕业的人作决定就不爽。

是不是说这个人的观点是应该在学校教授家庭经济，所以选C。原文并没有说不教授家庭经济的坏处，就不能放在结论中了。

飞天猪piggy · 发表于 2006-11-22 12:48:00

终于有人理了。。。谢谢zhy862001MM先

后来我仔细琢磨了一下这道题：题中说they are confronted daily with decisions relating to home economics说明学好home economics最多也就是make decision comfortably的一个充分条件而E中用了unless...把它当作了必要条件所以错

c的逻辑很严密甚至用了if...,then...(把含糊的relating to具体到了充分关系) 而且基本上概括了题干的中心思想所以对

大家来说说对不对呢？

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-11-22 12:49:14编辑过]

phileas · 发表于 2006-11-22 13:25:00

E的条件太绝对了，unless，never都上来了，而且离题较C远一些，楼主觉得哪？

飞天猪piggy · 发表于 2006-11-22 13:32:00

以下是引用phileas在2006-11-22 13:25:00的发言：
E的条件太绝对了，unless，never都上来了，而且离题较C远一些，楼主觉得哪？

phileas说的是 unless ，never这些次都太绝对了除非是原文的逆否命题一般看到就应该排除掉了

tamama · 发表于 2006-11-23 23:50:00

原文没有涉及到做决定的feeling,排除E

归纳题集中突破中--cxd一题请赐教