求助一道SC题，网上一点解答也查不到

阿斯加德小公主 · 发表于 2018-7-25 22:08:04

To estimate the expansion rate of the universe is a notoriously difficult problem because there is a lack of a single yardstick that all distances can be.

ATo estimate the expansion rate of the universe is a notoriously difficult measured by problem because there is a lack of a single yardstick that all distances can be
BEstimating the expansion rate of the universe is a notoriously difficult problem because there is no single yardstick by which all distances can be measured
CBecause there is a lack of a single yardstick to measure all distances by ,estimating the expansion rate of the universe is a notoriously difficult problem
DA notoriously difficult problem is to estimate the expansion rate of the universe because a single yardstick is lacking by which all distances can be measured
EIt is a notoriously difficult problem to estimate the expansion rate of the universe because by no single yardstick can all distances be measured

想正确答案是B，想请问一下E错在哪里，谢谢~

Jeremy.c · 发表于 2018-7-27 10:55:00

GMATclub论坛的解释：E：Meaning change, The text means to say that there is no single yardstick' but E says that a single yardstick(even if present) cannot measure all distances.

想问下A，你的选项是正确的吗？论坛上的A是：To estimate the expansion rate of the universe is a notoriously difficult problem because there is a lack of a single yardstick that all distances can be measured by. 我有点不理解A的错误。

Jeremy.c · 发表于 2018-7-27 10:59:53

哦懂A的错误了，因为介词不可以放在句子末尾，要放在前面写成by which。

RicoHo · 发表于 2018-8-5 10:28:36

1，no single yardstick 比 a lack of a single yardstick简洁 GMAT语法要点！简洁！简洁！简洁！重要的事情说三遍
2，一个句子一般不用介词结尾，所以用by which 修饰yardstick语义比较清晰
3，to do 放在句子开头不如动名词直接在开头，也是基于简洁原则
4，一般来说，句子主语最好是按原句要求不做更替所以D项肯定是不太好的

lw902 · 发表于 2018-8-28 11:56:24

RicoHo 发表于 2018-8-5 10:28
1，no single yardstick 比 a lack of a single yardstick简洁 GMAT语法要点！简洁！简洁！简洁！重要 ...

你好！想请教下第三点是根据经验得出的吗？还是哪份文档归纳总结过？

Jimmyfish2012 · 发表于 2018-10-15 04:07:03

我觉得按照gmat思路来思考的话，看看大神是不是这么觉得：

B 和D 其实是一个错误，那就是把这么重要的词当宾语，但是宾语根本就不长，没有必要用there is 或者it is 来开头。是不是，是不是？
根据精简原则，应该直接拿主语开头，

Jimmyfish2012 · 发表于 2018-10-15 04:09:04

说错了，和E. 不是D, d 的single yardstick改变原意了。中文：根本不是一把尺子能做到的（拿尺子做不到的)，而不是只靠一把尺子不行（言外之意，两把就可以了）

SamKboardW · 发表于 2018-10-29 12:49:08

先贴出来GMAT Club的讨论帖：https://gmatclub.com/forum/to-estimate-the-expansion-rate-of-the-universe-is-a-notoriously-268609.html

然后说一下自己的理解：
A-- "a lack of a single yardstick" 比起 "no single yardstick" 太罗嗦
句子最后的"by", 作为preposition一般不会放在句子最后

B-- 正确答案

C-- "a lack of a single yardstick" 同A,啰嗦
第一个clause的最后"by" 放置比较尴尬（待高手纠正）

D,E --这两个选项放在一起看，因为他们都把句子的意思改变了
D的主语成了a problem而不是estimating the expansion rate，后面虽然提出了estimate the expansion rate of the universe但是更像是举例子
E的主语也是a problem（同D), 而且最后 "no single yardstick can all distances be measured" 第一语序混乱，第二偷换概念，no single yardstick can 和 no single yardstick是两个概念，前者是有yardstick但是这个yardstick不能blablabla，后者是我们压根没有yardstick（缺的就是它）

fuckoffand · 发表于 2018-11-1 02:47:31

To estimate... is a difficult problem 其实犯了不平行的错误，一个是to do (verb) 一个是a difficult problem (noun)，可以看看曼哈顿的解释

qqtu · 发表于 2018-12-2 23:36:42

fuckoffand 发表于 2018-11-1 02:47
To estimate... is a difficult problem 其实犯了不平行的错误，一个是to do (verb) 一个是a difficult pro ...

这个切入点很好！赞思路

那么能不能用这个点排除e选项呢？

求助一道SC题，网上一点解答也查不到

所属分类: 下线版块

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()