HBS的招生思路单一到令人不解

caesar2005 · 发表于 2009-2-13 05:49:00

lz还是静心申请别的学校吧。hbs出来的牛人一大把，但也有一大把混混。能去hbs当然不错，但去不了，也不必心烦意乱。

商学院只是个锦上添花的东西，不要过度迷信它。如果你真的是个人才，就算是不去商学院，也能功成名就，如果是个庸才，就算是侥幸去了hbs，你也不会有多大成就的。

yi11 · 发表于 2009-2-13 07:56:00

以下是引用littleca在2009-2-13 4:38:00的发言：

Personally I don't believe in "overqualified". No matter how successful you think you are, at top b-schools you will always meet people who are more capable in different dimensions. And applicants can never be too successful to be recruited if you truly convince admission committee that an MBA is necessary.

HBS emphasizes impact a lot. What impact will you make to the world after graduation? Do you aspire to be a global business leader? If so, have you demonstrated your track record, your ambition and potential in your admission package?

It is common (and totally fine) that different schools have their own preferences screening candidates. Maybe it is time to think over your admission strategy and the "fit" between you and school.

And don't forget people tend to recruit candidates who are more likable. You centainly not want to work with a person who is aggressive / over confident and who blames other people when he/she fails.

Good Luck!

Point perfectly written. I recall reading somewhere that the first thing top b-schools look at applicants is how you peceive and position yourself in the context of the world. Simply assuming being the center of the world and ignoring others' accomplishments are sure signs of immaturity.

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-2-13 7:56:21编辑过]

koaladd · 发表于 2009-2-13 08:58:00

I am trying to follow the chain of posts here and have no idea where this comes from- See below bolded. Any hint?

以下是引用yi11在2009-2-13 7:56:00的发言：

Point perfectly written. I recall reading somewhere that the first thing top b-schools look at applicants is how you peceive and position yourself in the context of the world. Simply assuming being the center of the world and ignoring others' accomplishments are sure signs of immaturity.

superpapa88 · 发表于 2009-2-13 23:40:00

刚看到法国报纸上谈 HBS 录取的法国人. 此人本科是法国烂的不能再烂的考都不用考就能进去工程师学校 (HEI). 2004 年毕业在 Renault车间做了三年小组长. 去年就进了 HBS... Youngstar... oh my god! 总觉得如果你是欧美人, 念过大学, 工作过, 录取好的学校比大陆总是机会大. 是素质吗? no idea...

OrangeBlossom · 发表于 2009-2-14 03:12:00

说的真好。

asdf116699 · 发表于 2009-2-16 09:48:00

不可否认，TOP MBA学生都很优秀（包括这个论坛里面出现的TOP MBA男男女女就都是不世出的英才，我觉得），毕业生很多也很成功，

但说到家，毕竟，这些学校乐意录取的是适应西方文化（不一定是最精华的文化）的优秀人群中的一种类型（不必要是最容易成功的类型）而已，所以：

“优秀=TOP MBA=更成功”

这个公式从来也没成立过，现在，有人觉得它成立吗？

如此，何必耿耿于怀呢，哥们？

只是好多最优秀的人才他们没能录取进去，替他们惋惜就好了

feynman烨 · 发表于 2009-2-16 13:00:00

我不是很懂mba申请，太年轻只是商科硕士在读。

不过很久以前曾经在这个版上看过一句话

big cows are not in b-schools, those inside are cows-wanna-be.

可能学校觉得lz这样的不需要读b-school就已经能发展得很好了，所以觉得你没有读的意义。

wei2009 · 发表于 2009-3-21 01:18:00

以下是引用superpapa88在2009-2-13 23:40:00的发言：
刚看到法国报纸上谈 HBS 录取的法国人. 此人本科是法国烂的不能再烂的考都不用考就能进去工程师学校 (HEI). 2004 年毕业在 Renault车间做了三年小组长. 去年就进了 HBS... Youngstar... oh my god! 总觉得如果你是欧美人, 念过大学, 工作过, 录取好的学校比大陆总是机会大. 是素质吗? no idea..

haha, cute story. most Frenchmen don't really care US B-schools, because they don't like schools which are dominated by Americans. Europeans, at least Frenchmen and German as far as I know, they think their own culture and system are superior than American's. that's the fundamental difference between Chinese applicants and European applicants. Plus, in Europe, they have several awesome B-schools already, Insead, LBS, etc.

I also know a Malaysian who rejected HBS and chose Darden as he thought HBS was not for him and he loved Darden's culture.

So don't get obsessed by any brand.

HBS的招生思路单一到令人不解

回复：（yi11）以下是引用littleca在2009-2-13 4:38:0...

所属分类: 商学院申请

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()

浏览过的版块