灵魂提问，求问一逻辑题

1998JIN · 发表于 2019-10-2 12:42:30

29. Kayla: Many people are reluctant to shop in our neighborhood because street parking is scarce. The city plans to address this by adding parking meters with time limits that ensure that parking spaces are generally available. But this plan will surely backfire—shoppers dislike paying at parking meters, so most will probably drive to other neighborhoods to shop at malls with free parking.
Which of the following, if true, would be the most logically effective rebuttal a proponent of the city’s plan could make to Kayla’s objection?
A. Most shoppers dislike hunting for scarce street parking spaces much more than they dislike paying for metered parking spaces.
B. The city could post signs with street parking time limits to ensure that parking spaces become available without forcing shoppers to pay at meters.
C. Currently, most shoppers in the neighborhood drive only occasionally to shop at malls in other neighborhoods.
D. The neighborhood already contains a parking lot where shoppers must pay to park.
E. The nearby malls with free parking have no parking time limits to help ensure that parking spaces in their lots become available.

我练习逻辑也有好长好长一段时间了，唉，怎么还会觉得正确选项看起来怪怪的呢？
先求问D 为什么不对吧，其实这题我觉得没有一个对的，但是D对我迷惑性比较大
然后A。。。。
结论句是：But this plan will surely backfire
莫非A之所以是对的，在于虽然A 不能说明方案可行，但是至少说明不会使得情况更糟糕，所以也算是反驳了结论吗？（难道竟然是这样的吗？）

ShayneYang · 发表于 2019-10-3 10:44:11

D选项完全就是无关选项吧，引入了一个新的parking lot，这个parking lot跟整个题目没有关系，（文章中要讨论的是顾客对于这个NB停车场的偏好和其他NB免费停车场的偏好），然后A的话，换句话的意思就是比起车位收费，更多的顾客更讨厌没有车位，所以现在城市开始收车费来产生更多车位，就可以让来的顾客增加。

aprilfool916 · 发表于 2019-10-3 23:52:24

先理解好问句： Which of the following, if true, would be the most logically effective rebuttal 【a proponent of the city’s plan could make】 to Kayla’s objection? = Which one of the answer responses provides the best rebuttal to Kayla's objection?

Kayla believes the plan will have the opposite effect since people dislike paying for parking and are likely to shop instead at a mall where parking is free.

D：We are given no information concerning the cost or availability of parking in the parking lot, or its proximity to the shopping portion of the neighborhood. This doesn't help defend the plan. If anything, it is a factor against the plan.

A. Correct. Shoppers currently try to park on the streets where meters will be installed. These shoppers find searching for a parking space increasingly difficult. It is possible that shoppers actually dislike searching for parking spaces more than they dislike paying for parking spaces. If this is the case, there is no reason to believe that these customers will leave the neighborhood to shop elsewhere.

viivici · 发表于 2019-10-14 16:15:11

想请问一下如果选a的话，为什么不能像文中说的去其他mall购物？感觉选a等于假设其他mall的停车场车位也不足啊

ddflee · 发表于 2019-10-15 20:00:51

想问下这个B选项怎么错了呢？

语法学习爱好者 · 发表于 2019-10-24 21:38:23

ddflee 发表于 2019-10-15 20:00
想问下这个B选项怎么错了呢？

B选项的措施，并不是原来plan里面的内容。作为一种新的解决措施，与这个plan没有关系。

liyaz · 发表于 2020-1-4 10:38:56

求解为啥E不对呢

断了的弦 · 发表于 2020-4-23 20:41:52

viivici 发表于 2019-10-14 16:15
想请问一下如果选a的话，为什么不能像文中说的去其他mall购物？感觉选a等于假设其他mall的停车场车位也不 ...

我去，和我一样的想法，a是不是默认附近街区的mall车位也紧张，可是题干中好像说那车位随时有似的

灵魂提问，求问一逻辑题

所属分类: GMAT考试

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()