GWD7-38对参考答案的疑惑

yaoyao99

You're evaluating the argument, (fullfilling requirement => running for governor) not "did Bergeron really fullfill the requirement."

yaoyao99

E is more relevant in the causal relationship between the financial requirement and governor candidacy.  C merely undermines the basis of the argument, not the argument itself.

yaoyao99

Hmm. let's try approaching this differently.

If someone asks you to evaluate the validity of the argument "I bought 1000 lottery tickets today so I must have a good chance at winning it."  You won't think of evaluating it based on "did you really buy 1000 tickets" but the relationship between 1000 tickets and winning the lottery.

Hope that helps!