Michigan(no scholarship) Vs Emory (one-year program and 80% scholarship)

adios

以下是引用delphine18在2005-3-21 16:50:00的发言：

这里好象很多人说Michigan投资回报率不高，不知道是否有历届学生就业情况依据？

我倒并不是因为被Michigan录了才说它的好话，但至少在去年最新的wall street journal排名里，它是升到第一位的，wall street journal够讲投资回报率的吧？

另外，我从其它资料上看到过，在一项针对美国雇主的＂哪些学校的MBA受企业欢迎＂调查中，Michigan也是名列前茅的，因为毕业生作风务实、肯干，不象哈佛等学校的毕业生眼高手低，一副非管理层不做的样子（原话如此，不是有意贬低HBS的各位xdjm)

actually i have the same feeling.

ROIs for MIT, Ross, Berkeley etc. those traditionally techie schools are usually low.

unless you decide to get into IB, it may well take over 5 ~ 7 years to just break even.

but for applicants from mainland, as long as you can land a job in the States, or go to IB, MC (most of them are on global pay scale, means pay level the same no matter the geographic location), then you don't need to worry about ROI.

for young applicants in US, it is not a big deal eaiser. since most of the kids apply to b-school at their late 20's, the average salary probably are at 50k ~ 80k level (excludes the finance sector). then it is possbile to get your investment back in 5 years.

the toughest is for those guys in their mid 30's. w/ current pay over 100k, it is very unlikely they can get the 300k (100k tuition + 2 year's salary loss) back in even 10 years.

makebj

seems we are in the same shoes: I got full emory scholarship and michigan offer with no money. but I have one thing more important is that my wife also get 40000USD scholarship from emory. so I tend to go to emory

dullpen

真是羡慕makebj GG!

ceeyee

等学校的毕业生眼高手低，一副非管理层不做的样子

this is exactly what a school should equip us to think about ourselves.
皇者风范，就是hbs，很多时候实干者就给这些眼高手低的打工。

GSBDream2006

Ross of course. 50K$ is nothing if you graduate and find a job. you don't want to fell sorry in the future that you miss a top BS.

And congratulation!

ritazhouxx

大家各有各的意见了。。还是要根据自己情况来看吧！

飞雪

It really depends on your career goal. If you really want to get into Coca, you can try Emory. Otherwise, I would suggest you to mull it over. As you can look into the employers for both schools, that is something that you can really tell the difference. If you like, e-mail the one who have similar background with you in Michigan to find out the answer. I believe that you should have our contact info or you can find it in the yahoo group.

eternalwind

没搞错吧, MBA PROGRAM还看奖学金的? UMICH和EMORY根本就不是一级别的学校, 还犹豫什么.记住, 现在心疼那么点奖学金, 到时候毕业找工作的时候会更难受的

delphine18

以下是引用ceeyee在2005-3-21 23:29:00的发言：
等学校的毕业生眼高手低，一副非管理层不做的样子

this is exactly what a school should equip us to think about ourselves.
皇者风范，就是hbs，很多时候实干者就给这些眼高手低的打工。

算了吧，至少那个调查说不受企业欢迎的MBA别说让别人为自己打工了，连自己的工作都找不到

makebj

我一直比较困惑的一个问题是：一个学校，2年的时间，能改变一个人多少？回想大学4年其实也没学到什么东西。名校真出来的真的就这么神吗？我觉得关键还是看自己的性格和能力！不然大家对你的期望值太高，自己压力太大也挺痛苦的！自己想清楚吧！