- UID
- 988424
- 在线时间
- 小时
- 注册时间
- 2014-3-12
- 最后登录
- 1970-1-1
- 主题
- 帖子
- 性别
- 保密
|
贱才子 发表于 2015-7-1 15:32 ![]()
层主还是有点太武断了,但是我赞成大部分。
我觉得武断的点是:的确在S16的学校里,只有Sloan一家开设MS ...
ok, let me make it more clear like this:
US tier 1: M7
US tier 2: S16
US tier 3: may that up till to top 30
=> if it is not within top 16, it is alreay tier 3 in US.
why classify like this? simple, "tier" simply means a group, which the 1st is clearly better than the 2nd, but not significant difference within the group.
and it is quite clear that M7 > S16 > top 30, so top 30 is already tier 3. I think it is really clear. i.e. those three school are tier 3 in US.
(MIT is tier 1, and no tier 2 (S16) school offer a MSF, only some within top 30 (tier 3) does. I do think the gap is quite huge indeed..)
of course US business school is the strongest in the world, and say, a tier 1 business school in APAC may be at most tier 2 in US.........
and I don't mean (and I didn't say this here also) they 被HKU/HKUST碾压的程度 (in ranking / reputation), but:
1. at most similar in terms of reputation, so just don't worth the difference in tution. (HKU level is also BB 愿意看一眼 's level, HKUST is a bit better but difference are not huge <--- accounted for location already. That's true that BB favors US school, but simply because the top one are in US. Keeping this factor (kind of ranking) constant (and also language and ability), the location doesn't matter much indeed...)
2. location: getting a school in HK/SG will give one a better chances for a job there in terms of visa policy and location..........but US MSF for a job in US (as non-STEM)? chances are so slim as non-target + international that one can ignore
P.S. for example, I don't think it is suitable to compare two universities where both of them only have good local reputation......: say HEC or UT Austin better? It will be kind of useless to do such comparsion, but rather which country one want to go.......same case for, say NUS vs some top 30 US business school (visa policy + job market analysis more important than a simple number in ranking) |
|