OG11的一道题 望解答

sunyuwei

Computers are becoming faster, more powerful, and more reliable,and so too are modems, they are the devices to allow two or more computers to share information over regular telephone lines.

(A) so too are modems, they are the devices to allow
(B) so too are modems, the devices that allow
(C) so too modems, the devices allowing
(D) also modems, they are the devices that allow
(E) also modems, which are the devices to allow
这道题目解出来没有问题但是无关题目有个问题，望NN解答
划线部分之前的and 为什么会需要 就像 she likes watching movies, so do I/so I do 前面需要and 吗？还是可有可无？

Nagi

parallelism: X is good, and so too is Y

RIGHT        Bellbottoms ARE coming back in style, and SO TOO ARE vests.
SUSPECT        Bellbottoms ARE coming back in style, and ALSO vests.
WRONG        Bellbottoms ARE coming back in style, and SO TOO vests.

she likes watching movies, and I likes...too = and so do I这里是两句句子必须要有连词的

so I do 是加强语气表示肯定，和你的问题没关系吧...比如A：she likes watching movies. B: So she does. 是两句句子啊

sunyuwei

Nagi 发表于 2014-9-15 16:20
parallelism: X is good, and so too is Y

RIGHT        Bellbottoms ARE coming back in style, and SO TOO ARE  ...

不好意思我记错了，我记成了 AS
eg. I can deal with the thing, as I can/as can I

题外话：she likes watching movies, and I likes...too 之间的comma 去掉是否可行？是否是RUNON sentense?

Nagi

sunyuwei 发表于 2014-9-15 16:30
不好意思我记错了，我记成了 AS
eg. I can deal with the thing, as I can/as can I

你是说i can deal with the thing, as he can?

这里需要加as的，作为一个连词，意思相当于in the same way，是as三种连词的用法之一。
同样的，因为这里是两句句子，且是两个不同的人称，所以需要加逗号。

关于题外话：comma不可以去掉，因为两个句子并列，并列连词前必须加逗号。
<1>句子, and句子  She likes, and I like... or Mary likes..., and she likes ... too.
<2>do and do

manhattan原话：
Do not use a comma before and to separate two verbs that have the same subject. Either eliminate the comma, or add a subject to the second verb, creating a second main clause.
×Earl walked to school, AND later ate his lunch.
○Earl walked to school AND later ate his lunch.
○Earl walked to school, AND HE later ate his lunch.

sunyuwei

Nagi 发表于 2014-9-15 16:48
你是说i can deal with the thing, as he can?

这里需要加as的，作为一个连词，意思相当于in the same w ...

讲的非常清楚 给你无数个赞！

sunyuwei

Nagi 发表于 2014-9-15 16:48
你是说i can deal with the thing, as he can?

这里需要加as的，作为一个连词，意思相当于in the same w ...

我在Manhattan看到的原话不知道如何解释，请教
She worked hard and she made herself ill.
the one with just "and" -- is incorrect unless you are actually implying that these are two separate, independent things. for instance, if this woman worked really hard and then drank alcohol until she began to vomit, the first sentence would make sense. if working hard is the cause of her illness, then the sentence is incorrect.

Nagi

sunyuwei 发表于 2014-9-15 19:32
我在Manhattan看到的原话不知道如何解释，请教
She worked hard and she made herself ill.
the one wit ...

没见过的考点，不能100%肯定。
看上去字面意思是说and只能连接并列的句子，因此A and B成立的条件是AB之间是独立的，个人理解即是并列事件。
因此，他说如果AB之间有因果关系，就不能单纯用and连接了。

sunyuwei

Nagi 发表于 2014-9-15 21:04
没见过的考点，不能100%肯定。
看上去字面意思是说and只能连接并列的句子，因此A and B成立的条件是AB之 ...

我也是这样的理解 所以对于你上面说的两个并列的句子之间不能用单纯的and 连接我就疑惑了。。。望解答

Nagi

sunyuwei 发表于 2014-9-15 21:08
我也是这样的理解 所以对于你上面说的两个并列的句子之间不能用单纯的and 连接我就疑惑了。。。望解答 ...

我百度了一下，这个好像是曼哈顿论坛上的？不是书里的。

sunyuwei

Nagi 发表于 2014-9-15 21:21
我百度了一下，这个好像是曼哈顿论坛上的？不是书里的。

是的是论坛上的，那你的意思是这个结论并不一定100%正确是吗？你的说法是书里的是吗?