关于SC中遵从原句（A选项）的问题

heidiym

做到了这个题

Ryūnosuke Akutagawa’s knowledge of the literatures ofEurope, China, and that of Japan were instrumental in his developmentas a writer, informing his literary style as much as the content ofhis fiction.

(A) that of Japan were instrumentalin his development as a writer, informing his literary style as much as

(B) that of Japan was instrumentalin his development as a writer, and it informed both his literary style as wellas

(C) Japan was instrumental in hisdevelopment as a writer, informing both his literary style and

(D) Japan was instrumental in hisdevelopment as a writer, as it informed his literary style as much as

(E) Japan were instrumental in hisdevelopment as a writer, informing both his literary style in addition to

答案是C做对了，语法点的解释也明白了。只是有一个疑问在于关于尊总原句（A选项）的问题。因为确实是通过逻辑应该可以判断出knowledge informs literary style AND the content of his fiction. 表明style和content是并列的关系。但是我在回看CD之前的讨论帖的时候出现了一个疑问，就是因为A选项虽然可能as much as的比较是模糊的，但是我在想作者原意是不是在表达和强调style和content的程度才用了as much as呢？都说要在语法正确的情况下遵从原句意思，但是如果是C的话不就没有强调程度而跟原句意思有出入了呢？有人可能会说：因为别的as much as的选项都有语法的硬伤，只有C喽。但是我在想改变原句的意思或者强调的点是否也是一个硬伤呢？我在之前的帖子里没有找到答案，只有解释语法点的，所以请各位NN解惑啦~谢谢！

brfmzbjz

回答最后一句：不是

SC的选择 很多时候不是选the best one
而是选the least awkward one
在A选项没错的前提下 尽量遵循愿意 但这不是一个must
本题里 A 已经有严重语法问题 所以果断抛弃

heidiym

brfmzbjz 发表于 2014-7-6 10:57
回答最后一句：不是

SC的选择 很多时候不是选the best one

恩恩谢谢回答！

alzn2765

新东方最先提出A选项是原意的表达这个说法的，GMAC答疑会上讲过这个问题，根据OG的上的说法也没有A选项是原意的表达。
趋势是找逻辑意思最优的就对了。

heidiym

alzn2765 发表于 2014-7-7 11:35
新东方最先提出A选项是原意的表达这个说法的，GMAC答疑会上讲过这个问题，根据OG的上的说法也没有A选项是原 ...

好的谢谢 只是在做题过程中越发看到各种解释是与“与原句意思不符，与原句逻辑不一致，与原句强调对象不一样”。这个被当成一个很重要的理由去解释选项了，所以我一直不清楚到底这是不是一个绝对性错误。感觉可能也是大家做题做多了的经验，即使OG没说逻辑是按照A选项的，很多正确选项都是通过认同A选项的逻辑意思才正确的，估计是大家总结的吧。

alzn2765

新东方就是喜欢把多数情况的问题变成“定理化”、“绝对化”，想上700分不能这么搞。

heidiym

alzn2765 发表于 2014-7-11 09:52
新东方就是喜欢把多数情况的问题变成“定理化”、“绝对化”，想上700分不能这么搞。 ...

是的 语言这个东西要好好理解融会贯通才好