HKUST MBA在香港到底有多大竞争力

jeff1439

Jason要好运 发表于 2014-4-6 22:11
感觉新加坡NUS和NTU的MBA太烂了 所以在考虑美国和hkust的 想知道hkust出来到底能有多好 ...

how bad ? any facts or data to support your point of view.

.. sounds like you are in the ops, IT or business analysis division .. it is not the core business  of a bank.. is your company top 2 in the industry ?

it should be a good decision to study in US, if you have been in SG for years !

Jason要好运

jeff1439 发表于 2014-4-7 00:17
how bad ? any facts or data to support your point of view.

.. sounds like you are in the ops, IT ...

don't have data but know some facts, not sure how to show you. some friends graduated from NUS MBA, but can't find a good job, even not as good as what they did before MBA. at least, what can be confirmed is that most ppl from NUS MBA can't find an elite job.

I am in regional bank(DBS) as a Business Analyst, not a global bank. consider HK because i want to move back to China someday, and I only focus Asia market in the future. any good suggestion if you are saying move to US is a good decision.

jeff1439

Jason要好运 发表于 2014-4-8 22:36
don't have data but know some facts, not sure how to show you. some friends graduated from NUS MBA ...

I have sufficient facts and data, thus I have a different opinion from what you said ....

It took me sometime to think about your comments and how to help..... let me ask you several questions first, hope these questions could give you a clue..

(a) a lot of good schools out there, but how many good companies ? more good companies or more good schools ? How many graduates from a good school each year ?
(b) can a good school guarantee everyone a job, can a good school gruanatee most graduates elegant jobs ?
(c) how many companies in this world hire MBA ? are they hiring average people or very selected people ?

for your friends ,are they chinese or singaporean, when did they graduate, was the macro economic enviroment good, back to the time ? what are their previous background, DBS or top international firms ? whether are they in the industries, which value the MBA education ( there is no demand for MBA in some industry or companies)... demand/ supply.... all these things matter !

For MBA --- If a person is weak in work expr, then s/he shall consider to drive him/herself to be strong in another area.. pick the right location, indusry, position, education ...
most top 15 U are in US..... but top school also can not gurantee a top job for everyone....MBA sounds good, but might not be proper for everyone ( some people are not good at managing things in nature), cost is also very high ...

I won't continue to follow this post, you could find out more by doing more research

dodudodu

generally HKUST and NUS are of the same tier, although UST ranks higher...if the post-MBA objective is IB and consulting, better go for US top 10/EU top 2..I did witness those graduates who successfully switched their career...but if they went for Asia business schools, they wouldn't be able to find the same job..btw, I did have a conversation with NUS AO, their responses to my questions regarding employment is quite ambiguous.

DerekS

dodudodu 发表于 2014-4-9 09:20
generally HKUST and NUS are of the same tier, although UST ranks higher...if the post-MBA objective  ...

What did they say?

Jason要好运

dodudodu 发表于 2014-4-9 09:20
generally HKUST and NUS are of the same tier, although UST ranks higher...if the post-MBA objective  ...

my objective is top tier iB.  compared to HKUST or NUS MBA, how do you think London Business School - Master in Finance

dodudodu

Jason要好运 发表于 2014-4-9 20:58
my objective is top tier iB.  compared to HKUST or NUS MBA, how do you think London Business Schoo ...

MF不是很了解……不过投行对欧美顶尖商学院的认可度绝对大于亚太的，MF毕业也有人进GS MS的（非back office）

stella1881

想通过hkust , nus 去 goldman sachs / morgan stanley 的 IB front office ... 基本上没可能的  , 除非你本来就是干这行业的, 想从小firm 跳去大firm ,  或者你有人脉去干wealth management

Jason要好运

stella1881 发表于 2014-4-11 11:21
想通过hkust , nus 去 goldman sachs / morgan stanley 的 IB front office ... 基本上没可能的  , 除非你 ...

那么london business school的master in finance可以吗

Jason要好运

stella1881 发表于 2014-4-11 11:21
想通过hkust , nus 去 goldman sachs / morgan stanley 的 IB front office ... 基本上没可能的  , 除非你 ...

或者duke, Michigan的MBA可以吗