lsat-test27-sec4-22

donna

Sarah:some schools seek to foster a habit of volunteering in their students by requiring them to perform community service. But since a person who has been forced to do something has not really volunteered and since the habit of volunteering cannot be said to have been fostered in a person who has not yet volunteered for anything, there is no way thin policy can succeed by itself.
Paul:I disagree. Some students forced to perform community service have enjoyed it so much that they subsequently actually volunteer to do something similar. In such cases, the policy can clearly be said to have fostered a habit of volunteering.

The main point at issue between Sarah and Paul is whether
(C)being forced to perform community device can provide enjoyment to the individual who is forced to perform such service
(D)it is possible for school to develop policies that foster the habit of volunteering in their students
答案是C,但我选了D

cranberry

文中萨拉的意思是：由于强迫做事不是真正的自愿，而没有自愿的做事就不能认为是养成了自愿的习惯，所以单单这种方式是不能成功的。保罗的意思是许多学生在被强迫做义工后，开始主动做义工了，所以政策是有效果的。她们的争议是政策能否有效的使学生养成了习惯，即这种政策能否让学生喜欢上了自愿做义工，而不是D所说的是否可能制定出什么样的政策来达到这个目的，政策是既存的，政策的效果是重点，而不是制定的可能性。

tocean0222

In contrast to Sarah's claim that students cannot develp a habit of volunteering through performing community service forced by some schools, Paul argues that one's habit of volunteering  can be stimulate by the enjoyment of performing such service.Thus the main point is clear.D is not discussed in the argument. It will be the answer only if it is changed to "the policy adopted by schools is possible to foster  a habit of volunteering of students".

iamnone

我有个疑问, 根据原文Sarah DID NOT MENTION ANYTHING ABOUT ENJOYING,NOT EVEN ABOUT THE ENJOYMENT CAN FOSTER HABIT TO VOLUNTERING