OG13 52 题求解。。对OG的解释不太明白

vividlai

To Josephine Baker, Pariswas her home long before it was fashionable to be an expatriate,

and sheremained in France

during the Second World War as a performer and an intelligence

agent for theResistance.                                                            

(A) ToJosephine Baker, Paris

was her home long before it was fashionable to be an expatriate

(B) ForJosephine Baker, long before it was fashionable to be an expatriate, Paris

was her home

(C) JosephineBaker made Paris

her home long before to be an expatriate was fashionable

(D) Longbefore it was fashionable to be an expatriate, Josephine Baker made Paris

her home

(E) Long beforeit was fashionable being an expatriate, Paris

was home to Josephine Baker

看了elory的OG解释，和OG自己的解释，都说AB中的her多余，意思重复。。不知道怎么理解。。求解

victor198506

我认为和A,B选项中的her没多大关系
A选项中and 前子句的主语是Paris，但and 后面的子句主语是she，这样违反了parallelism原则
B选项中错误地使用了it去指代Josephine Baker
C选项中的to be用的不合适，因为句子叙述的事发生在过去。
D,E选项中错误地使用了being

victor198506

sorry...应该是E选项错误地使用了being

rylstar01

To Josephine Baker, Paris was her home long before it was fashionable to be an expatriate...

说下我的观点，以A为例，之所以认为her是重复的。
原因在于起Paris前面的To Josephine Baker，可以清晰的表达了Paris是谁的家了。
To Josephine Baker, Paris was home.
这样的话，简洁而且不会有歧义。
不过还可以从LS说的角度出发，根据逻辑主语进行解答。

Sdx1993

to do做主语和that引导的主语从句在GMAT中都是不允许的，相比之下，it做形主形宾以及同位语这两个句型更受GMAT的喜爱。
我认为原文应该是说”移居国外很流行之前“的意思，但to be an expatriate 做主语是不合适的。

kida

贴一个我搜到的解释，正好解释了lz的疑惑吧。

As a general rule, it would be redundant to have a pronoun refer to a noun directly preceding it and separated by a comma - both can act as the subject of the same clause, and it's unclear which is the subject. .

Incorrect: GMATMadeEasy, he is a clever boy.

It makes sense if the prnoun itself is the subject or object or a second clause

Correct: GMATMadeEasy is a clever boy, but he doesn't like pronouns

In the correct sentence, the pronoun "he" refers to the noun GMATMadeeasy, but the difference is that that the pronoun is now the subject of a new clause, as evidenced by the conjunction "but", and the fact that both the noune and the pronoun have their own main verb.

原网站：http://www.beatthegmat.com/to-josephine-baker-paris-was-her-home-long-before-t9860-15.html