求助一道GWD语法

熊的传人

Critical-thinking instruction is predicted on two assumptions: that there are clearly identifiable thinking skills that students can be taught to recognize and apply appropriately, and if recognized and applied, students will become more effective thinkers.

A.if recognized and applied, students
B.if these skills are recognized and applied, that students
C.if students recognize and apply them, that they
D.that if recognized and applied, students
E.that if students recognize and apply these skills, they
此题为什么不选D？~~我觉得D主语SKILLS 被省略了。 很合理啊。。D的话感觉比较啰嗦 难道又是主动大于被动？

DUKB24

D选项if省略是主语不是skills，是students （你考虑的是从句中的主句和从句）你不能跳出这两个结构去考虑逻辑主语

wyw1018

D选项if条件省略句的逻辑主语成了students，错。

TerraceHo

同意lss。
對於if/although/though/when等連詞，如果從句的subject與主句相同，而且從句使用的是be動詞的話，可以將[subject + be]同時省略，只留下剩下的成份。

that if【students are】recognized and applied, students will become more effective thinkers.

另，主動優於被動不能作為排除選項的standard，除非已經排除到只剩下2-3個的情況。當然，可以優選。

熊的传人

好吧~~~考虑逻辑主语是错误了

Hendy

有的时候做题也不能光读者顺口， 更要看句子意思