prep2012 sc36

sherryuk

In a state of pure commercial competition, there would be a large number of producing firms, all unfettered by governmental regulations, all seeking to meet consumer needs and wants more successfully than each other.
A.all seeking to meet consumer needs and wants more successfully than each other
B.all seeking more successfully to meet consumer needs and wants than the others
C.each seeking to meet consumer needs and wants more successfully than one another
D each seeking to meet consumer needs and wants more successfully than the others
E each seeking more successfully to meet consumer needs and wants than another
答案是D
但是 seeking 和wants 不平行啊
我选的是B 两个all…… 都做firms的同位语  把needs and wants 看成名词 不对吗？？
谁能帮着分析下D 的结构……

sisichen666

D选项考查的是：each 型独立主格结构,强调前面半句句尾名词regulations,形式为:

句子 + 复数名词结尾, each + 介词短语/形容词短语/-ed形式/-ing形式；
LZ要是选择了B-all，对应wants单数动词形式——主谓绝对不一致了啊

DUKB24

In a state of pure commercial competition, there would be a large number of producing firms, all unfettered by governmental regulations, all seeking to meet consumer needs and wants more successfully than each other.
A.all seeking to meet consumer needs and wants more successfully than each other
B.all seeking more successfully to meet consumer needs and wants than the others
C.each seeking to meet consumer needs and wants more successfully than one another
D each seeking to meet consumer needs and wants more successfully than the others
E each seeking more successfully to meet consumer needs and wants than another
答案是D
但是 seeking 和wants 不平行啊
我选的是B 两个all…… 都做firms的同位语  把needs and wants 看成名词 不对吗？？
谁能帮着分析下D 的结构……

-- by 会员 sherryuk (2012/11/2 18:32:45)

我觉得这个all 和each开头都可以


关键你还是要从语义上去分析


后面是一个比较结构


你all后面的比较是什么？each other或者the others


这并不符合逻辑


句子想要传达是，在一个特定的群体中


每个人都争先恐后的干嘛




是一个特定群体中（某人和某人的比较）


而不是一个特定的总群体和某人的比较




说的比较不清晰


望LZ可以明白我在说什么= =

sherryuk

楼上的解释看懂了 但是还是不明白 and是让seeking 和wants平行吗？？  这种平行可以吗？

897560818

wants是和needs平行

粽子小姐

这里考得是each独立主格结构，不能用all引导

emmahiggins09

我不是很同意楼上的说法，曼哈顿说了独立诸葛可以用all 引导。而且第一个用all 引导的就是独立诸葛

jieyukathy

1. each other 和 one another 都是 reciprocal pronoun，表示对象之间互相怎么怎么样，但是实际上这道题的原文知识简单的比较而已，无需表示互相之间的关系，所以A，C排除
    例如：The brothers love each other. = The elder brother loves the younger. And the younger loves his brother too.
    原题：Each firm wants to meet the consumers' needs and wants than the others do.
2. 副词的位置的放置，曼哈顿里特别强调过副词位置的放置对句意的影响。B和E的more successfully都放在seek之后，修饰seek和原文的意思是不一致的。原文要表达的意思是more successfully meet consumers' needs and wants，所以错误。
3. 综上D正确。复数名词，each v-ing/v-ed 的独立主格结构使用表示强调；each后没有用reciprocal pronoun。

seaner

sherryuk 发表于 2012-11-3 15:37
楼上的解释看懂了 但是还是不明白 and是让seeking 和wants平行吗？？  这种平行可以吗？ ...

wants 和need是在一起的