乱谈Top 10（麻烦各位不要太乱，得有个度吧）

Shuzhen

东北的沃顿吸引了如下中国的精英在向你所说的雪花菲菲大步迈进（来源：wharton S2S: http://s2s.wharton.upenn.edu）.  Cheers for both them and you：

From:  JUNLI6   Nov-17 8:32 pm  To:  ALL   (1 of 15)    6274.1  

I know there are many applicants from China. Why don't we introduce ourselves and get to know each other?

I am currently working in Shanghai with 4 years work experience in consulting and private equity. Just got the interview invite on Nov.17th. Will take the hub interview here in Shanghai.

From:  JASON_QIU   Nov-18 10:15 pm  To:  JUNLI6   (2 of 15)   6274.2 in reply to 6274.1  

Hey,

Would you like to share your perspective on the interview? I am targeting round 2.

Jason

From:  JUNLI6   Nov-18 11:09 pm  To:  JASON_QIU   (3 of 15)  6274.3 in reply to 6274.2  

Will have my interview on Dec 5th. I can share with you after I finish it.

From:  JASON_QIU   Nov-19 1:30 am  To:  JUNLI6 unread  (4 of 15)   6274.4 in reply to 6274.3  

Great. Finger corssed for you. Look forward to your good news!

Jason


From:  ZHUBIN   Nov-19 5:31 am  To:  JUNLI6   (5 of 15)  6274.5 in reply to 6274.1  

Hi, Junli6,

good luck to your upcoming interview!

I am working in Shanghai, too. Going to apply in the round 2.

zhubin

From:  QWCHEN   Nov-27 1:55 am  To:  JUNLI6   (6 of 15)   6274.6 in reply to 6274.1  

Hi,Junli6,

I now work in Shenzhen and scheduled the interview on Dec.5. Maybe, we can share some ideas by email. My email box is qwchen@sse.org.cn.

Best

Quanwei Chen


From:  JUNLI6   Nov-27 3:37 am  To:  QWCHEN   (7 of 15)   6274.7 in reply to 6274.6  

Good idea! Will drop you an email!

From:  LILOJ   Nov-27 3:45 am  To:  JUNLI6   (8 of 15)   6274.8 in reply to 6274.7  

hi,

i'm r1 applicant, just back to shanghai from philly, visiting the school and conducted the interview on campus last friday.

nice meeting everyone here,

jenny


From:  MZENG2   Nov-27 5:03 am  To:  LILOJ   (9 of 15)   6274.9 in reply to 6274.8  

oh wow you flew all the way acorss the world? now that's something!

hope your interview went well

by the way I was born in China and came here when I was really young but I do consider myself an applicant from china

good luck with your interviews, I'm doing an alumni interview next weekdn

From:  LILOJ   Nov-27 5:38 am  To:  MZENG2   (10 of 15)   6274.10 in reply to 6274.9  

so you're in states and didn't make the on campus interview?.....mmmmm....

hehe, actually, on campus inteview had pros and cons, i was compared with native speakers and the interview was conducted by a 2nd year student which lasting only 30 minutes.

anyway, we'll see. wish you good luck!

Shuzhen

打个比方，tuck看上去就像你的邻家女孩，她不象hbs公主那样高高在上，也不象stanford富姐那样珠光宝气，更不象wharton女郎那样目光犀利。可是有一天你心血来潮，去敲门约她出去踏青，结果只会发现你实际上是那天下午第156个造访的男孩。

atongmu

今天看到一个老外争论的帖子。他们好像有一个什么M7之说。

1.  The Dean pointed out that most of Columbia抯 peer schools are reexamining their pre-term programs, recognizing that business schools are much more heterogeneous today than they were several years ago. Columbia Business School is part of a seven-school consortium that includes Harvard, Stanford, Wharton, Kellogg, Chicago and Sloan.  All seven schools are considering building a joint on-line module that would be part of a more extensive pre-term program for incoming students.   

2.  The Financial Times MBA 2000 ranking shows many similarities to the 1999 survey but it also throws up some surprises.  At the top of the table are the self-annointed group of seven top US business schools: Harvard Business School, the Wharton school at the University of Pennsylvania, Stanford, the Sloan school at MIT, Columbia, Chicago and Kellogg at Northwestern University.   

3.  The Magnificant Seven Meet: Safwan Goes to the Semi-Annual Vice Dean抯 Meeting.  The top seven business schools share information several times a year. The Deans of each school meet twice a year and the Vice Deans meet separately twice a year (in case you抮e wondering, the schools are Harvard, Wharton, Columbia, Stanford, Kellogg, MIT, and Chicago). Here is Safwan抯 account of the most recent Vice Deans meeting, which took place here at Columbia two weeks ago.  

BL: What is this group?

SM: The group consists of the seven self-anointed great private business schools. We meet with our peers twice a year, primarily to benchmark against one another, to discuss topical issues that affect us all, and to collaborate.  

4.  The European clubs of Columbia, Chicago, Harvard, Kellogg, MIT-Sloan, Stanford and Wharton Business Schools are presenting the first edition of their European recruiting event: MBA Eurotrek 2003.  The MBA Eurotrek 2003 will connect leading companies based in Europe with 400+ first and second year MBA candidates from seven top US business schools. For more information visit: http://www.mbaeurotrek.com/

atongmu

我认为卖咸菜能卖出名堂才是牛人，比那些在MC和IB的随波逐流的“精英”强得多！

可怜的Duke，永远的top10，为什么进不了常委呢？

chipmunk

Actually M7 do exist. The Dean of those 7 private schools hold meeting every year, discussing about common issues, like score-non-disclosure.

Shuzhen

(转贴）

(1) Harvard

(2) Stanford       Wharton

(3) Chicago       Kellogg       Sloan@MIT

(2) Columbia      Tuck@Dartmouth

(5) Fuqua@Duke       Johnson@Cornell       Yale       Michigan       Darden@Virginia

(3) Stern@NYU       Hass@UCBerkeley       Anderson@UCLA

(3) Carnegie Mellon       McCombs@Texax-Austin       Kenan-Flagler@UNC-Chapel Hill

(5) Goizueta@Emory       Olin@WU in St. Louis       Indianna       Simon@Rochester       McDonough@Georgetown

(4) Smith@Maryland       Marshall@SCU       Mendoza@Notre Dame       Krannert@Purdue

(4) Fisher@Ohio State      Smeal@Penn State      Broad@Michigan State       DuPree@Goergia Tech

(3) Thunderbird       Babson       Wisconsin-Madison

Shuzhen

偶在家里综合business week排名（16年的纵向对比），今天忘记带了，下次带来给大家。偶的方法是将每一个上榜的学校的16年的排名（2年一次，共8次）加起来除以8。如果有的学校只上榜4次，就加起来除以4。


印象好像是kellogg第一（Business Week 很青睐Kellogg的），wharton第二，Michigan第三，Harvard第四，Chicago第五，Stanford第六。


这个方法的好处是有一个纵向的历史的立体的比较，能够反映在人们印象中各个学校的地位。缺点是不能反映最新动态，比如Yale在近几年的急速上升，Michigan的急速下降，等等。


详情请等明天或下周。

at3

我是无缘这些牛校了，能读个三流学校也满足了

Shuzhen

澍镇排名法：综合business week排名（16年的纵向对比，2年一次，共8次），将每一个上榜的学校的16年来上过榜的排名加起来除以上过榜的次数。如果有的学校只上榜4次，就把四个排名加起来除以4。 （此排名法是版主澍镇辛勤回报Chasedream，转载请注明出处！）



这个方法的好处是有一个纵向的历史的立体的比较，能够反映在人们印象中各个学校的地位，因为一两年的排名未必能够改变大家的印象。（此排名法是版主澍镇辛勤回报Chasedream，转载请注明出处！）


缺点有二：
一是不能反映最新动态，比如Yale在近几年的急速上升，Michigan的急速下降，等等。（此排名法是版主澍镇辛勤回报Chasedream，转载请注明出处！）
二是不能反映其他媒体的排名，仅仅引用了BusinessWeek的数据，而BusinessWeek显然比其他媒体更加青睐Kellogg。（此排名法是版主澍镇辛勤回报Chasedream，转载请注明出处！）


排名                                         学校名                                                                                                             8次排名平均分数
    1                                                                             Kellogg                                                                                                             1.625
    2                                                                 Wharton                                                                                                  2.375
3                                                                             HBS                                                                                                                              3.5
    4                                                                             Chicago                                                                                                     5.375
5                                                                                     Michigan                                                                                                  5.5
6                                                                                     Stanford                                                                                                     7
7                                                                                 Columbia                                                                                              8.125
8                                                                                         Tuck                                                                                                                           9.25
9                                                                                         Fuqua                                                                                                                 9.75
10                                                                                 Darden                                                                                                             10.125


此排名法是版主澍镇辛勤回报Chasedream，转载请注明出处！


11                                                                                     Sloan                                                                                                                     10.375
12                                                                                     Johnson                                                                                                         11.875
13                                                                                     Anderson                                                                                                 12.875
14                                                                                         CMU                                                                                                                              13.5
15                                                                                            Kelly at Indianna                                                                            14.75
16                                                                             Kennan-Flagner                                                         14.875
17                                                                                             Stern                                                                                                                                 15.125
18                                                                                                     Hass                                                                                                                                     16.625
19                                                                                                     UT-Austin                                                                                                     18.5
20                                                                                                     Yale                                                                                                                                             18.8


此排名法是版主澍镇辛勤回报Chasedream，转载请注明出处！


21                                                                                     Olin at WU-St. Louis                                                 20
22                                                                                                         Simon    at Rochester                                                 21.8
23                                                                                             Marshall                                                                                                                                    22
24                                                                                             Cox at Southern Methodist                 23
24                                                                                                                 Wisconsin                                                                                                                            23        
26                                                                                                                 Owen at    vanderbilt                                                                     23.25                    
27                                                                                                                     Purdue                                                                                                                                         23.75
28                                                                                                         Smith at Maryland                                                                     24.6
29                                                                                                             Goizueta                                                                                                                                    25
29                                                                                                                     Thunderbird                                                                                                             25


此排名法是版主澍镇辛勤回报Chasedream，转载请注明出处！


31                                                                                                         Michigan    State U.                                                                                26
32                                                                                                                                 Georgetown                                                                                                             28
33                                                                                                                                 Notre Dame                                                                                                                 29
34                                                                                                                             Georgia Tech                                                                                                     30                                    


此排名法是版主澍镇辛勤回报Chasedream，转载请注明出处！