请教OG13 61如果换成each states 和all other states对比呢？

wmcmomo

61. While all states face similar industrial waste problems, the predominating industries and the regulatory environment of the states obviously determines the types and amounts of waste produced, as well as the cost of disposal.
(A) all states face similar industrial waste problems, the predominating industries and the regulatory environment of the states obviously determines
(B) each state faces a similar industrial waste problem, their predominant industries and regulatory environment obviously determine
(C) all states face a similar industrial waste problem; their predominating industries and regulatory environment obviously determines
(D) each state faces similar industrial waste problems, the predominant industries and the regulatory environment of each state obviously determines
(E) all states face similar industrial waste problems, the predominant industries and the regulatory environment of each state obviously determine

关于BD选项，OG说each state must ge compared to all other states  那么如果把D选项改成each state faces similar industrial waste problems, the predominant industries and the regulatory environment of all other states obviously determine
这样是否就正确了？是否存在改变了原句语义的问题？

wmcmomo

求搭理……

icever

61. While all states face similar industrial waste problems, the predominating industries and the regulatory environment of the states obviously determines the types and amounts of waste produced, as well as the cost of disposal.
(A) all states face similar industrial waste problems, the predominating industries and the regulatory environment of the states obviously determines
(B) each state faces a similar industrial waste problem, their predominant industries and regulatory environment obviously determine
(C) all states face a similar industrial waste problem; their predominating industries and regulatory environment obviously determines
(D) each state faces similar industrial waste problems, the predominant industries and the regulatory environment of each state obviously determines
(E) all states face similar industrial waste problems, the predominant industries and the regulatory environment of each state obviously determine

关于BD选项，OG说each state must ge compared to all other states  那么如果把D选项改成each state faces similar industrial waste problems, the predominant industries and the regulatory environment of all other states obviously determine
这样是否就正确了？是否存在改变了原句语义的问题？

-- by 会员 wmcmomo (2012/9/16 15:47:25)

这个解释该如何理解？
我的理解是这样的：
用each逻辑不通
每个人面临类似的问题，逻辑错误
大家面临类似的问题，正确

OPD

维以不永伤6

翻译一下楼主那句话：
当每一个州面对相似的垃圾问题，所有州的主导产业和法规环境决定了产生的垃圾的种类和数量以及处理垃圾成本。
首先，每一个州面对相似的问题，既然是“每一个”，那么跟谁比较相似呢，逻辑上说不过去。
所有州的……决定了……，这里明显是想说在states面对相似问题的时候，每个state有自己不同的垃圾的情况。

sisichen666

LZ的改写明显逻辑不对呀，LS写得已经很清楚（参考一下），还有一般来讲，都是先说集体共性用all，再说个体特性each，就会带来的问题或是情况~~~~