[求助]LSAT-8-4-8 做了两遍都没选出C

vendetta · 发表于 2005-10-29 22:15:00

答案应该是B，排除C的关键在于C项中"in response to smaller audiences"，尤其是smaller这个词，这是比较后的状态，而非比较前的假设。另外顺便说一下，假设C是假设，且假设如果音乐会的场数增多人们一定会来听，但来听的前提是什么，依然是B啊。

xjlv128 · 发表于 2006-4-20 15:33:00

我也觉得是B。题目里没有提到percentage的概念，排除总数这个他因没有用处啊

XUBIAO · 发表于 2006-5-22 22:52:00

音乐会人数下降,但音乐会场次没变,说明音乐会空位随时可有,这就说明NEW M对参加音乐会无兴趣.

所以我支持C

yboo · 发表于 2006-5-23 00:01:00

sounds like a B to me.

仅从题目给出的信息中看，buyers和concert goers完全没有任何联系（没有提到前者去过concert）。所以是两个完全不同的人群。

在结论中，则跟concert goers, 一点关系也没有，只是在说new buyers。所以，C是无关的。

B则把buyer和conert联系起来。

kingme · 发表于 2006-5-26 13:08:00

I think it's 'B'.

linxi107 · 发表于 2006-5-29 18:47:00

官方答案肯定是B，此题陈向东的逻辑书上有讲解，虽然我还是没搞懂

jane1109 · 发表于 2006-8-6 20:29:00

the correct answer is C. think of it this way, if the number of live concernts in the country have decreased, then it's no wonder the number of audiences who will ATTEND the concerts will decrease. Then the decrease in number of audiences to the concerts is not as result to people preferring records over live performances, thus the conclusion will be wrong. B is wrong, because it is about OPINION, not AVAILABILITY of concerts. Even if people had the OPINION of going to the concerts, they might still not want to go due to the CONVENIENCE of recordings, that will not contridict with the argument's conclusion. So by using the denial test, C is correct.

zxzhyzcy · 发表于 2007-5-15 19:11:00

zxzhyzcy · 发表于 2007-5-15 19:14:00

好大的争议哦~

到底是什么呢？

我也选了B~但是仔细想想觉得C也不错~好像都挺能assume,晕了~

icewarm · 发表于 2007-5-23 04:07:00

The answer is B. "opinion" should be "option".

[求助]LSAT-8-4-8 做了两遍都没选出C

所属分类: 法学院申请

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()