OG 语法 135题 求指导 谢谢~！！！！

Lhitachii

135.  Spanningmore than 50 years, Friedrich Muller began his career in an unpromisingapprenticeship as a Sanskrit scholar and culminated invirtually every honor that European governments and learned societiescould bestow.  
(A)          Muller began his career in anunpromising apprenticeship as
(B)         Muller's career began in anunpromising apprenticeship as
(C)          Muller's career began with theunpromising apprenticeship of being
(D)         Muller had begun his career withthe unpromising apprenticeship of being  B
(E)          the career of Muller has begun withan unpromising apprenticeship of




正确答案是B，可是那个culminated即以。。告终已经是过去式了，那在这之前的began为什么不能用D中的过去完成时had begun呢，毕竟开始是在过去的过去吧？？
请指导下~~~~~~~谢谢~！！！

泾渭不凡

1、时态问题：过去完成时的使用要谨慎，要有明确的时间提示或是逻辑前后语义表明才能使用。具体知识点讲解：prep语法笔记-part1--->172、176、220（A选项）。manhattan记得也有讲解，但是抱歉偶对小曼亲不熟悉，LZ自己查一下吧~ o(╯□╰)o。

2、逻辑主语问题：句首Spanning，逻辑主语应该是career，从逻辑含义上分析，先排除AD了。建议LZ同学先从逻辑上理解句意之后，排除逻辑含义错误的句子；再从语法点分析。

Lhitachii

1、时态问题：过去完成时的使用要谨慎，要有明确的时间提示或是逻辑前后语义表明才能使用。具体知识点讲解：prep语法笔记-part1--->172、176、220（A选项）。manhattan记得也有讲解，但是抱歉偶对小曼亲不熟悉，LZ自己查一下吧~ o(╯□╰)o。

2、逻辑主语问题：句首Spanning，逻辑主语应该是career，从逻辑含义上分析，先排除AD了。建议LZ同学先从逻辑上理解句意之后，排除逻辑含义错误的句子；再从语法点分析。

-- by 会员 泾渭不凡 (2012/3/31 15:43:24)

谢谢~！！！

99qiuqiu

楼主可以看看这题

Emily Dickinson’s letters to Susan Huntington Dickinson, which were written over a period beginning a few years before Susan’s marriage toEmily’s brotherand ending shortly before Emily’s death in 1886, outnumber ...


这里是不是begin 早于end，但是同样没有用perfect tense，原因在于：


（1）从平行角度，...beginning....and ending; began.....and cultivated...更好


（2）从时态上，过去完成时的目的在于 to clarify or emphasize the time sequence 时才用到的，这里begin和cultivate 的sequence不需要perfect tense。

Lhitachii

楼主可以看看这题

Emily Dickinson’s letters to Susan Huntington Dickinson, which were written over a period beginning a few years before Susan’s marriage toEmily’s brotherand ending shortly before Emily’s death in 1886, outnumber ...


这里是不是begin 早于end，但是同样没有用perfect tense，原因在于：


（1）从平行角度，...beginning....and ending; began.....and cultivated...更好


（2）从时态上，过去完成时的目的在于 to clarify or emphasize the time sequence 时才用到的，这里begin和cultivate 的sequence不需要perfect tense。

-- by 会员 99qiuqiu (2012/3/31 17:10:13)

理解了~~谢谢你~！！