求助~语文分册第二版 38题

橙色的鱼

A study commissioned by the Department of Agricul­ture showed that if calves exercise and associated with other calves, they will require less medication and gain weight quicker than do those raised in confinement.
(A)  associated with other calves, they will require less medication and gain weight quicker than do

(B)  associated with other calves, they require less medication and gain weight quicker than

(C)  associate with other calves, they required less medication and will gain weight quicker than do

(D)  associate with other calves, they have required less medication and will gain weight more quickly than do

(E)  associate with other calves, they require less medication and gain weight more quickly than

Choice E, the best answer, uses the adverbial phrase more quickly than to modify the verb phrase gain weight. In A, B, and C, quicker than is incorrect because an adjective should not be used to modify a verb phrase. E is also the only choice with consistent verb tenses. The first verb in the clauses introduced by showed that is exercise. A and B incorrectly compound that present tense verb with a past tense verb, associated. C and D correctly use associate, but C follows with the past tense required and D with the present perfect have required. Both C and D incorrectly conclude with the future tense will gain.

橙色的鱼

请问下大家E里边为什么非要省略do呢 看语法笔记的时候说的是主谓结构才可以省略，不然会有歧义~~

橙色的鱼

还有一般是if a do, b will do~~
e
在这里也例外了~~有没有童鞋能帮忙解释下呢

橙色的鱼

dddd

99qiuqiu

请问下大家E里边为什么非要省略do呢 看语法笔记的时候说的是主谓结构才可以省略，不然会有歧义~~

-- by 会员 橙色的鱼 (2012/3/30 14:35:08)

关于E中不存在非要省略do的意思，同样只要无歧义省略do是行得通的。

meridianzhuang

比较结构助动词补出是为了确定比较对象必须是前一个句子的主语,但是than后的句子已经有了动词了不应该再补出了,对吗?

橙色的鱼

这里我理解的是比较gain weight和gain those raised 哪一个更quick,童鞋你觉得呢？我是不是想的太偏了哦

99qiuqiu

比较结构助动词补出是为了确定比较对象必须是前一个句子的主语,但是than后的句子已经有了动词了不应该再补出了,对吗?

-- by 会员 meridianzhuang (2012/4/1 18:00:52)

than 后面的动词？你指的是？

99qiuqiu

这里我理解的是比较gain weight和gain those raised 哪一个更quick,童鞋你觉得呢？我是不是想的太偏了哦

-- by 会员 橙色的鱼 (2012/4/6 21:04:34)

不偏不偏，但是如果你这么想，那是不是require less...跟谁比呢？


还有其实这到题错误选项很明显的，就是补出的助动词不对。


还有，表达一下自己对于语法的解题观点：
那就是不要拿一道题的答案推出来的结论当成rule去套其他题。因为大家选出的是right 的答案但不一定是best的


个人观点，哈哈

橙色的鱼

这里我理解的是比较gain weight和gain those raised 哪一个更quick,童鞋你觉得呢？我是不是想的太偏了哦

-- by 会员 橙色的鱼 (2012/4/6 21:04:34)

不偏不偏，但是如果你这么想，那是不是require less...跟谁比呢？


还有其实这到题错误选项很明显的，就是补出的助动词不对。


还有，表达一下自己对于语法的解题观点：
那就是不要拿一道题的答案推出来的结论当成rule去套其他题。因为大家选出的是right 的答案但不一定是best的


个人观点，哈哈

-- by 会员 99qiuqiu (2012/4/7 6:39:36)

经过你的点拨，我豁然开朗了~~因为前面一个是HAVE一个是REQUIRE所以后面只用DO也是不对的~`THANKS A LOT！！