再论GWD6-41

蓝妹妹

Q41:
The greatest road system built in the Americas prior to the arrival of Christopher Columbus was the Incan highway, which, over 2,500 miles long and extending from northern Ecuador through Peru to Southern Chile.

Columbus was the Incan highway, which, over 2,500 miles long and extending
Columbus was the Incan highway, over 2,500 miles in length, and extended
Columbus, the Incan highway, which was over 2,500 miles in length and extended
Columbus, the Incan highway, being over 2,500 miles in length, was extended
Columbus, the Incan highway was over 2,500 miles long, extending
答案选E,

The greatest road system built in the Americas prior to the arrival of Christopher Columbus was the Incan highway，大家都说这个分句和Incan highway是同位语，可是我觉得
如果把他看成分句则应该是独立主格结构，即：
Being the greatest road system......, the Incan highway.........
而B 选项则构成了一个完整的倒装结构，extended为过去式，仍表主动

这个题以前讨论过，但我仍觉得疑惑

LES

独立主格结构的一个重要特点是其逻辑主语不同于主句的主语。

paraglider

看不到别人的发言啊！！！！

三脚猫

E的谓语动词是哪一个，Ｂ又错在哪里？

paraglider

同意楼上观点。选B

msfox

E的谓语动词是Was,

B中说road system extend，句子意思没有E表达的明确。

ethyl

独立主格结构的一个重要特点是其逻辑主语不同于主句的主语。

Nod!

独立结构常常可以看作是由主从复合句中的从句变来的。但是，如果从句和主句的主语相同，则不可改为独立结构。例如：

Since he was very tired with his walk，he soon fell asleep and forgot his troubles．

不可改为：

He being very tired with his walk，he．．．

但可改为：Being very tired with his walk ，he．．．

melodyji

以下是引用ethyl在2005-5-23 11:16:00的发言：

。

Nod!

独立结构常常可以看作是由主从复合句中的从句变来的。但是，如果从句和主句的主语相同，则不可改为独立结构。例如：

Since he was very tired with his walk，he soon fell asleep and forgot his troubles．

不可改为：

He being very tired with his walk，he．．．

但可改为：Being very tired with his walk ，he．．．

是不是应该 Very tied with his walk, he......

soar

以下是引用ethyl在2005-5-23 11:16:00的发言：

独立主格结构的一个重要特点是其逻辑主语不同于主句的主语。

Nod!

独立结构常常可以看作是由主从复合句中的从句变来的。但是，如果从句和主句的主语相同，则不可改为独立结构。例如：

Since he was very tired with his walk，he soon fell asleep and forgot his troubles．

不可改为：

He being very tired with his walk，he．．．

但可改为：Being very tired with his walk ，he．．．

还是改为Tired with his walk,he........好些吧，而且您的例子不像独立主格。

xjlv128

恩,同位语