拍拍求教~OG12 SC 1 ~~~谢谢好心人~~(第三遍做OG了。。。)

peddy

1。The Glass House Mountains in Queensland, Australia, were sighted in 1770 by the English navigator Captain James Cook, bv whom they were named supposedly because its sheer wet rocks glistened like glass.

(A)by whom they were named supposedly
because its

(B)by whom they were named supposedly and their

(C)naming them supposedly since their

(D)who so named them supposedly because their

(E)who so named it since supposedly their

求教c选项：As the object of a preposition and not the subject of the clause, James Cook does not work as the noun that the verbal phrase beginning with  naming can describe; 是说naming不能修饰JC么？为什么？

the prepositionsince loses the important causallogic of the sentence. SINCE 表因为的时候只有连词的属性，为什么这里说是介词？而且为什么这里用SINCE表示因为不可以？

求教D选项：supposedly位置改变，但OG并没有说它修饰不当，请问这是修饰不当么？~


谢谢大家~~~

hlaboratory

作为一个刚刚开始准备GMAT的新手，谈谈我个人的看法。
首先我第一眼看到题目，认为选项只可能是C或者D。
The Glass House Mountains in Queensland, Australia, were sighted in 1770 by the English navigator Captain James Cook, bv whom they were named supposedly because its sheer wet rocks glistened like glass.

而这里JC是处于一个介词短语之中，所以naming就人为将其拆分了，所以不合适。

而D选项我也只是根据语感，动词+宾语+修饰性的副词

我语法不是很好，说的不对请见谅

eshopaholic

选D

首先，排除有it或its的选项
其次，外表与名字是个因果关系，排除B
最后，若是naming them...，逻辑主语应该是整句句子主语（mountains),不合理，排除C

coolkof

C选项中naming的动作发出者是Mountains，不是JC。since可以用，但是如果和because比较，because更能表达原因解释
D选项的supposely修饰取名的动作，放在name的前后都可以，不影响

此题思路为，首先根据单复数原则，排除AE，再根据逻辑含义排除B，因为选项中的and前后不并列；接着排除C，解释如上

teddybearj4

如果是C选项的话是“，v-ing”形式，他是不能修饰comma前面的名词的。如果要用C选项，naming是伴随主句的动作were sighted发生，且逻辑主语是句子主语mountains，所以语意上来讲是不对的。
如果V-ing要做modifier的话，一定不要加comma！！！只有“n.+V-ing”的时候V-ing才是做定语修饰前面的n.。

hlaboratory

是否如果用Naming就可能引起歧异，不知它指的是哪个

teddybearj4

不是歧义，是这句话意思就不对了。
区别V-ing和which的用法。
1、S+V+O, V-ing……这个Ving的逻辑主语一定是applies to S的。如果他想做O的修饰语就错了。如果是做O的modifier是S+V+（O+V-ing），括号里面整个是一个宾语。
2、S+V+O，which……这个which一定是修饰O的。如果按句子的意思是修饰S的，一定错。因为这样子which就变成修饰前面整个句子了。

yiayia

V-ING用法参考：
http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_SC/thread-648003-1-1.html
昨天讨论的~

peddy

作为一个刚刚开始准备GMAT的新手，谈谈我个人的看法。
首先我第一眼看到题目，认为选项只可能是C或者D。
The Glass House Mountains in Queensland, Australia, were sighted in 1770 by the English navigator Captain James Cook, bv whom they were named supposedly because its sheer wet rocks glistened like glass.

而这里JC是处于一个介词短语之中，所以naming就人为将其拆分了，所以不合适。

而D选项我也只是根据语感，动词+宾语+修饰性的副词

我语法不是很好，说的不对请见谅

-- by 会员 hlaboratory (2012/2/6 12:11:53)

恩~是的是的~ OG说主动在这里比被动好，WHO SO NAMED 好于 BY WHOM THEY WERE NAMED~ 所以A,B,C不选~谢谢~~

peddy

C选项中naming的动作发出者是Mountains，不是JC。since可以用，但是如果和because比较，because更能表达原因解释
D选项的supposely修饰取名的动作，放在name的前后都可以，不影响

此题思路为，首先根据单复数原则，排除AE，再根据逻辑含义排除B，因为选项中的and前后不并列；接着排除C，解释如上

-- by 会员 coolkof (2012/2/6 12:27:57)

可是副词修饰的位置不是很重要么？并且应该紧跟修饰词，我觉得e改变了SUPPOSELY的位置所以不太对。。。求指导~