OG12 SC127 关于C选项的解释（看了讨论帖没有明确答案啊）求帮助！

haileylu

127。Joan of Arc, a young Frenchwoman who claimed to be divinely inspired, turned the tide of English victories in her country by liberating the city of Orléans and she persuaded Charles VII of France to claim his throne.
(A) she persuaded Charles VII of France to claim his throne
(B) persuaded Charles VII of France in claiming his throne
(C) persuading that the throne be claimed by Charles VII of France
(D) persuaded Charles VII of France to claim his throne
(E) persuading that Charles VII of France should claim the throne

正确答案是D，我也懂。但是不太明白C的解释啊
“a person cannot be said to persuade a clause(that the thrown be claimed), a person persuades another person or other entity” 这句话是什么意思啊？
我知道这道题用逻辑意思可以很清楚的排除C选项，但是OG的这个解释实在令人困惑啊
求牛牛指点~

fdrandom

OG是说，persuade不能接从句吧，只能是persuade sb/sth

haileylu

OG是说，persuade不能接从句吧，只能是persuade sb/sth

-- by 会员 fdrandom (2011/9/9 13:54:51)

谢谢，仔细看了一下确实是这个意思，顺便查了一下persuade 的用法
persuade 及物动词，用法有
persuade sb. to do sth. 说服某人做某事
persuade sb that...   使某人相信
persuade sb of sth.  使某人相信某事

geniealice

Here persuading is linked to liberating, but even if it were said that Joan did turn the tide of English victories by persuading Charles to claim the throne, a person cannot be said to persuade a clause (that the thrown be claimed), a person persuades another person or other entity.

OG的C选项说，即使是by persuading C to claim the throne，也不能说persuade一个从句（persuade that），人说服一个人或者一个个体。

--
明白不能+从句的问题，但是：
by persuading C to claim the throne 这种方式能用吗？？

ftdonnaf

我觉得ls改的句子可以唉。。。
by肯定不能省略；然后persuade 一定要用sb to do 不能用从句

tanklance

和正确答案D相比，A里面多了一个she为什么就不对了？

smileyleung

tanklance 发表于 2014-10-3 20:16
和正确答案D相比，A里面多了一个she为什么就不对了？

因为同平行的两部分都是同一个主语, 不用重复主语. 除非and前面有逗号

Mahoneisme

请教个问题：定语从句主谓取决于所修饰的名词，但可以通过单复数保持跳跃修饰。 He is the only one of seven students who goes to Yale.  这句话从GMAT语法分析来讲对吗  

tanklance

smileyleung 发表于 2014-10-9 22:04
因为同平行的两部分都是同一个主语, 不用重复主语. 除非and前面有逗号

所以加了she只是相对来说没有D那么简洁，但语法上并没有错？