GWD10 Q24

ssxxtt27

GWD-10-Q24

For the last five years the Dutch economy has grown faster than Britain, France, or Germany
, with the unemployment rate having remained well below that of the other three countries.


A.Britain
, France, or Germany, with the unemployment rate having remained
B.have those of Britain, France
, or Germany, and the unemployment rate remaining
C.have Britain, France
, and Germany, and the unemployment rate has remained
D.the economy of Britain, France
, and Germany, with the unemployment rate that has remained
E.the economies of Britain, France
, and Germany, and the unemployment rate has remained
答案是E 我的疑问是：解析说D选项的逻辑主语是dutch economy.但是with短语在这里其实是个with+n结构，并不是独立主格。何谈逻辑主语？

xyc19901015

同顶！而且我也不明白为什么dutch economy 不能做逻辑主语呢？

xyc19901015

顺便问一下怎么样判断with型独立主格结构的逻辑主语是否正确呢？独立主格的逻辑主语是动作的实际执行者或者承受者吗？那with sth+ing怎么跟逻辑主语进行理解呢？

xyc19901015

再顶！求NN解答

kicuna

我觉得这个答案比较明显呀,比较的是economy,所以Dutch和B、F、G的经济比，economy和unemployment是并列的关系，and连接，has grown和has remained平行了阿  不知道解释的对不对啊

ssxxtt27

顺便问一下怎么样判断with型独立主格结构的逻辑主语是否正确呢？独立主格的逻辑主语是动作的实际执行者或者承受者吗？那with sth+ing怎么跟逻辑主语进行理解呢？

-- by 会员 xyc19901015 (2011/8/12 14:05:41)

你道出了我长久以来的困惑。。

ssxxtt27

我觉得这个答案比较明显呀,比较的是economy,所以Dutch和B、F、G的经济比，economy和unemployment是并列的关系，and连接，has grown和has remained平行了阿  不知道解释的对不对啊

-- by 会员 kicuna (2011/8/12 17:19:13)

谢谢，你解释的很对。其实这道题对于答案来说，已经很清晰。我只是想知道D选项错在哪，还有with结构已经逻辑主语等等相关的知识点，如楼上讨论。

tubai

顶顶顶 求NN解答啊

ssxxtt27

顺便问一下怎么样判断with型独立主格结构的逻辑主语是否正确呢？独立主格的逻辑主语是动作的实际执行者或者承受者吗？那with sth+ing怎么跟逻辑主语进行理解呢？

-- by 会员 xyc19901015 (2011/8/12 14:05:41)

昨天刚弄明白。独立主格结构不考虑逻辑主语。你可以看看笔记上关于独立主格的知识点，都没有说逻辑主语的问题。
需要考虑逻辑主语的情况http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_SC/thread-583230-1-1.html