牛人来看一道SC GWD

zlljolie

For many revisionist historians, Christopher Columbus has come topersonify devastation and enslavement in the name of progress thathas decimated nativepeoples of the Western Hemisphere.

Decimated大面积死亡毁灭

A.devastation and enslavement in the name of progress that has decimated native peoples of the Western Hemisphere

B.devastation and enslavement in the name of progress bywhich native peoples of the Western Hemisphere

decimated

C.devastating and enslaving in the name of progress those nativepeoples of the Western Hemisphere which in the name of progress are decimated.

D.devastating and enslaving those native peoples of the westernHemisphere which in the name of progress are decimated.

E.the devastation and enslavement in the name of progressthathavedecimated the native peoples of the Western Hemisphere.
从语意上看，我觉得应该选E。GWD给的答案是A，that从句修饰progress，我觉得是修饰devastation and enslavement这种跳跃修饰。大牛们怎么看啊？

balapupu

看的好晕额。。。

balapupu

有没有人能具体分析一下每个选项？

wangmenghan

主语Christopher Columbus， 谓语 has come to personify,宾语devastation and enslavement
B by which 是怎么BY 的 ，总得有个动词加by 吧，那个定从里没有动词宾语，哪来的by

C 名词为什么要变成动名词啊，更何况后面一长串的结构如此之混乱。which指谁啊，those是干嘛的

D 和C一样
E  progress that have！！！ progress 是单数好不好，要用也得用has 啊

在做语法题得时候，记住一点，每个选项之间的差异点才是考点，差异是很容易看出来的，所以一比较就知道谁对谁错

nemiah

E的the devastation and enslavement 前面的the不好，变成了特指。 而原意不是。。 。

xuanlingxiang

to justify it, the answer is A, according to prep.