GWD30-41 语法 求助贴

lollipop90

Elk now live almost solely in the Rocky Mountains, which would make it seem that elk are mountain dwellers, while they once ranged over virtually all of the continental United States except for a small strip in the extreme Southwest.

1. Elk now live almost solely in the Rocky Mountains, which[CH1] would make it seem that elk are mountain dwellers, while
   
   

The fact that elk now live almost solely in the Rocky Mountains would make it seem that they are mountain dwellers, but

It would seem that elk would be mountain dwellers because of their living[CH2] now solely almost in the Rocky Mountains, but still

Now living[CH3] almost solely in the Rocky Mountains, it would seem that elk were mountain dwellers, although

It seems that elk would be mountain dwellers from the fact that they now live solely almost in the Rocky Mountains, since[CH4]

[CH1]Which不能指代前面的句子


[CH2]One’s doing错；almost位置变化了


[CH3]Live的主语不是it指代的that主语从句


[CH4]前后属于转折关系，不应该用since

所以答案说是B，但是我认为，B中的it 指代不清，而且文中的elk是复数，指一个种族中的人，怎么能用it带呢！！！！
有木有！！！

lollipop90

anyone knows the answer?

salle66

it是一個形式主語呢，形式主語一般說的是整件事，因為The fact that....那分句太長，沒有特別的一個名詞要指代，用it指的是這件事。

換個角度來想，it也不可能只帶fact,因為這樣這個fact seem that...邏輯不通啊，fact怎麼可能seem that...

例如這樣的例子吧。

The fact that she is unexperienced made it impossible to complete the target.
這個it一定要在這，作為形式主語，但不是來指代fact的。

這樣講明白麼？

lollipop90

it是一個形式主語呢，形式主語一般說的是整件事，因為The fact that....那分句太長，沒有特別的一個名詞要指代，用it指的是這件事。

換個角度來想，it也不可能只帶fact,因為這樣這個fact seem that...邏輯不通啊，fact怎麼可能seem that...

例如這樣的例子吧。

The fact that she is unexperienced made it impossible to complete the target.
這個it一定要在這，作為形式主語，但不是來指代fact的。

這樣講明白麼？

-- by 会员 salle66 (2011/5/20 9:22:14)

你不觉得你换的这个角度使得你的解释更加矛盾吗？
就是指代不清这个it.

yanxihua00

我是这样做题的，A明显错，which原因   DE不对，语义理解，C和B选择，意思差不多，但是C中有个still, 还有their living 等，不太好，B是答案

wendydou

seem 是一个动词和形式主语中的difficult不一样 ··所以我认为B中it 依然指代不清

典座

salle66 发表于 2011-5-20 09:22
it是一個形式主語呢，形式主語一般說的是整件事，因為The fact that....那分句太長，沒有特別的一個名詞要 ...

这..........这段话copy的是另一个帖子里的回答吧.........
建议下次移过来的时候写下reference~