OG 12 SC 85

naoyixue

85.  Salt deposits and moisture threaten to destroy the
Mohenjo-Daro excavation in Pakistan, the site of an
ancient civilization that flourished at the same time
as the civilizations in the Nile Delta and the river
valleys of the Tigris and Euphrates.
(A)    that flurished at the same time as the
civilizations
(B)    that had flourished at the same time as had
the civilizations
(C)    that flourished at the same time those had
(D)    flourishing at the same time as those did
(E)    flourishing at the same time as those were

为啥不能用过去完成时， 逻辑上过去的过去已经繁荣， 但是这个过去的过去的时间和civilizations in the Nile Delta 是同样的时间？ 而且had又平行。 谢谢，。 （还是划线划不出来，问下，应该怎么划）谢谢

大马oz

85.  Salt deposits and moisture threaten to destroy the Mohenjo-Daro excavation in Pakistan, the site of an ancient civilization that flourished at the same time as the civilizations in the Nile Delta and the river valleys of the Tigris and Euphrates.
(A)    that flurished at the same time as the civilizations
(B)    that had flourished at the same time as had the civilizations
(C)    that flourished at the same time those had
(D)    flourishing at the same time as those did
(E)    flourishing at the same time as those were


发新帖的时候有编辑器，划线是一个选项，像word一样吧。


过去完成时不对，是因为这里没有需要比较时间先后的时间状语或逻辑意思。而且，B选项中，后面的那个had多余了。

naoyixue

en 慢慢悟，谢谢。

cheesecake00

有个问题一直没人讨论过，在这道题解析的选项上面那段话说”the clause correctly uses the simple past tense, flourished,to describe civilizations that existed simultaneously“

谁能帮我解释一下，为什么A选项中的flourished，这个一般过去式，可以表示出civilization的时间相同？

谢谢！！

slgbond

首先,这个句子,描述的是一个历实,
巴基斯坦莫亨朱达罗文明, 和, 尼罗河三角洲/(底格里斯河和幼发拉底河)流域文明,
发生在同一个时间,这个是历史,是作者无法改变的,所以用过去时来描述一段事实
然后用The same ....as 做了对比,
at time,说明fourish时间上是一样的,所以A

slgbond

这两个词,在这个句子里的释义比较关键,理解对了,句子就简单了,
这是我的拙见,请G友们参考
excavation (挖掘出来的)古迹/文物
site (一个古老文明的)遗址

cheesecake00

首先,这个句子,描述的是一个历实,
巴基斯坦莫亨朱达罗文明, 和, 尼罗河三角洲/(底格里斯河和幼发拉底河)流域文明,
发生在同一个时间,这个是历史,是作者无法改变的,所以用过去时来描述一段事实
然后用The same ....as 做了对比,
at time,说明fourish时间上是一样的,所以A

-- by 会员 slgbond (2012/1/8 19:47:59)

我觉得我昨天把问题想偏了。。。谢谢！！

小小knut

有个小问题 如果 没有没有歧义 如果没有在比较重补充出助动词 是不是就算错？

the site of an ancient civilization that flourished at the same time as the civilizations （did） 那如果加上did呢？？？